We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
1. An 18-inch, sterling silver double heart necklace to remind them that you're better together or that two hearts beat as one. You know, some romantic stuff.
2. A pair of sparkly square stud earrings because they're made with glitter and will immediately turn every outfit into a party (remember those?).
3. A heart birthstone necklace that'll make them think you spent way more than you did. Each white-plated gold necklace features crystal birthstones and zirconia stones, and comes with a gift box and gift bag for easy gifting.
4. A gold chain because they'll want to throw it on with every single outfit, especially on would-be romantic date nights. Siri, play "UnCHAINed Melody."
5. A pair of RBG-inspired "Dissent Collar" earrings to give any justice-loving super diva who's on the Supreme Court of your heart. A portion of every purchase of these nickel-free earrings goes to three nonprofit organizations.
6. A custom coordinate necklace because you can personalize it with the location of your first date, first smooch, or somewhere else that's special to the both of you (like your favorite Taco Bell).
7. An antique-inspired ring set (with a band and an antique heart-cut ring) that can be worn together as a set or individually. And no, it doesn't count as two gifts.
8. A personalized necklace in gold, rose gold, or platinum-plated for your king or queen so they know how much they mean to you not only on Valentine's Day but every other day of the year as well.
9. A pair of Kate Spade earrings so they can wear their heart on their lobe. These dainty studs are shaped like the love notes you used to put in your middle school crush's locker.
10. A short and long layered necklace with lobster-claw clasp, rhinestones, and a simple bar to tell your special someone that they sparkle every single day.
11. A set of Betsey Johnson black heart stud earrings that'll make even the blackest of hearts feel something (Is...is that love?). Each heart is adorned with black crystal accents that may or may not be darker than their soul!
12. A faux pearl necklace and earring set to make your valentine feel like royalty. These baubles are made from sterling silver, cubic zirconia, and aaa+ pearls for a luxurious look.
13. A pair of handmade tassel earrings because they're just plain fun, like your loved one. These statement earrings are gold-plated, nickel-free, and measure a little over three inches long.
14. A quartz necklace so chic they'll never want to take it off. It's perfect for date night but will also make them look put together on work Zoom calls.
15. An adjustable friendship bracelet that'll tell them just how much you love them. This lightweight bracelet is woven and able to withstand water if they decide to take it for a polar plunge.
16. A Fossil chain bracelet with a dazzling heart embellishment because it's perfect for anybody who likes to wear their heart on their sleeve.
17. A stackable heart ring because maybe you're not quite ready to give a diamond ring. Or maybe they already have one and just need something to stack with it. Whatever stage you're in, this sterling silver ring is sure to make them smile.
18. Dangly stud earrings for anybody who's not into hearts but loves to get jewelry for Valentine's Day. They even come with a gift box so you won't have to break out your wrapping paper.
19. A smartwatch that'll make sure they're on time for your next date. Plus, it's got a monitor that'll alert them every time you make heart skip a beat.
20. A pair of Multi-hoop earrings because they'll make your valentine say "hoop there it is." And is there anything more romantic than that?
21. A trio of anklets to remind them that warmer weather is on the way, which is the best gift of all.
The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.