Melissa Joan Hart as Sabrina Spellman ABC, Jemal Countess / Getty Images Magical fact: Melissa revisited her iconic role as Sabrina in a 2011 Funny or DIe sketch called "Sabrina & Salem: Together Again." Caroline Rhea as Aunt Hilda ABC, Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images Magical fact: Caroline can be seen as one of the celebrity panelists on ABC's Match Game this summer. Beth Broderick as Aunt Zelda ABC, Michael Loccisano / Getty Images Magical fact: After Sabrina, Beth had a recurring Role as Diane Janssen on Lost. She also appeared on two episodes of Melissa Joan Hart's show Melissa & Joey. Nate Richert as Harvey Kinkle ABC, instagram.com Magical fact: Nate hasn't professionally acted since 2006 — these days he works full time as a musician. Oh, and he's really funny on Twitter. Jenna Leigh Green as Libby Chessler ABC, Monica Schipper / Getty Images Magical fact: Sabrina wasn't Jenna's only witchy project! She played the role of Nessarose and Elphaba's understudy in the National Tour (and eventually the Broadway production) of Wicked. Soleil Moon Frye as Roxie King Vivien Killilea / Getty Images Magical fact: By the time Sabrina rolled around, Soleil was already a household name — as a kid, she played the role of Punky Brewster on Punky Brewster from 1984-1988. Martin Mull as Principal Willard Kraft ABC, Roy Rochlin / Getty Images Magical fact: Martin is starring in a new sitcom called The Cool Kids, coming to Fox this fall. Elisa Donovan as Morgan Cavanaugh ABC, Angela Weiss / Getty Images Magical fact: Wondering why Elisa always looked so familiar? She played the iconic role of Amber in Clueless — both in the film and the TV show. Lindsay Sloane as Valerie Birkhead ABC, Jonathan Leibson / Getty Images Magical fact: She's still. Big. Red. Yes, it's true — speaking of iconic red-headed roles from our youth, Lindsay played the villainous Big Red in Bring It On. David Lascher as Josh ABC, Mike Coppola / Getty Images Magical fact: David Lascher's last IMDB acting credit was in 1999 — with one fun exception: He appeared in two episodes of Melissa Joan Hart's show, Melissa & Joey. BONUS: Nick Bakay as Salem Saberhagen ABC, Jason Merritt / Getty Images Magical fact: Yup, meet the man behind our favorite cat! In addition to voicing Salem on the show (and the animated Sabrina series) Nick also provided the voice for Norbert in The Angry Beavers.