Skip To Content

    30 Products That Prove Peanut Butter And Chocolate Are The #1 Couple

    Of course this is mostly stuff to eat. I wouldn't do you wrong.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. A gourmet nutty cups subscription because why yes, it would be quite lovely to get a box of these shipped to your door every month.


    The cups are made with almond and peanut butter. Each box will contain six of the stock flavors and at least two special flavors of the month.

    Get it from Cratejoy for $16+/month (available in boxes of 8 or 15 cups).

    2. Or a 16-pack of nutty cups you'll wanna snag some pics of before you enjoy.

    Uncommon Goods

    Get them from Uncommon Goods for $38.

    3. A bag of Reese's cups filled with Reese's Pieces because yes your dreams have finally come true and of course you can purchase them.


    Get them from Target for $4.29 (and pick up a bag of Reese's Pieces too while you're at it).

    4. A Reese's-scented candle because you'll also keep the flame burning for the best thing to happen to the candy aisle.

    Maarvelous Creations / Etsy

    Get it from Maarvelous Creations on Etsy for $10+ (available in two sizes).

    5. Salted chocolate peanut butter cotton candy I would easily annihilate in one sitting. Um, I think I just found your new movie night snack.

    Sugar and Spun / Etsy

    Get it from Sugar and Spun on Etsy for $6.

    6. Fresh baked peanut butter chunk cookies — two whole pounds of them! — shipped right to your door after a few mere clicks.

    David's Cookies

    Get them from David's Cookies for $36.95 (available in four sizes).

    7. Or chocolate peanut butter cookies in case you prefer a complete and total union of your fave couple.

    2smartcookiesbakery / Etsy

    Get them from 2smartcookiesbakery on Etsy for $17.99.

    8. RX chocolate peanut butter, which is really just fancy talk for a jar of your fave stuff, without all the ingredients you don't recognize.


    I've been a huge fan of RX bars awhile and feel the same way about their nut butters! NOW, I put just about any kind of junk food into my body but even *I* appreciate the transparency for the ingredients.

    Get two jars from RX for $15.99 (also available in a 10-pack of squeeze packs).

    9. Or Peanut Butter & Co Dark Chocolate Dreams Peanut Butter, a budget-friendlier option in a jar that'll help satisfy your cravings and get your bake on.


    Get it from Target for $3.99 (also available in a white chocolate version).

    10. Chocolate peanut butter puffs because I know I can't have been the only who's been munching on a Cheeto and thought "What if?!"


    Get them from Mouth for $5.50.

    11. The Cheesecake Factory Reese's peanut butter chocolate cheesecake you can have allllll to yourself. Not by the slice! By the dang cake, my friend!

    Harry & David

    Get it from Harry & David for $99.99.

    12. Magic Milk straws that'll transform a glass of skim into a full-on dessert. I think you just got booked for a "got milk?" ad.

    Economy Candy

    Get a pack of four straws from Economy Candy for $1.99.

    BTW, Economy Candy is a NYC small biz that's doing lots of cool candy care packages right now because you might as well satisfy that sweet tooth. (I ordered a few for friends!)

    13. Justin's peanut butter cups in bite-size noms ready to savor.


    Get them from Target: milk chocolate for $4.99 or dark chocolate for $6.49

    14. Chocolate covered espresso beans peanut butter because we all deserve something that you want (no, feel your body's NEED) to eat straight out of the jar.

    Reid's Gourmet / Etsy

    Get it from Reid's Gourmet on Etsy for $10.49.

    15. Dipped Oreos that'll almost be too good looking to eat. JK.

    Mullendore Farm / Etsy

    Get a six-pack from Mullendore Farm on Etsy for $10.

    16. A ~decadent~ chocolate bar set that'll feel like a real treat. Only one has PB in it, but variety is the spice of life!

    Uncommon Goods

    Get them from Uncommon Goods for $34.

    17. Gourmet coffee sure to put even more pep into your sweet-tooth step.

    Harry & David

    Get it from Harry & David for $12.99 (also available as a subscription or in pods).

    18. A special spoon made to get out every last bit of the good stuff. Just think, that stuff stuck inside the jar is missing out on all the good times with its BFF chocolate syrup.

    Uncommon Goods

    Promising review: "We use it regularly for the various nut butters we use. You can easily get every last bit out of the jar." —K

    Get it from Uncommon Goods for $12.

    19. And a PB-specific spoon for EATING, which you'll also use plenty.

    Sams Coffee Gifts / Etsy

    Get it from Sams Coffee Gifts on Etsy for $8.99+ (available in combo packs of up to five).

    20. Pretzel nuggets because why not throw in another delish flavor into the mix? The extra saltiness will do your taste buds good.

    World Market

    Get them from World Market for $6.99.

    21. Peanut butter milkshake malt balls that come in a cute lil' snack box you'll wanna part at your desk station to treat yourself as constructing a "circling back" email. (You know what I mean.)


    Get them from Sugarfina for $7.95.

    22. Tiger fudge you needn't have watched Tiger King to devour. Though you could devour it while watching. In fact, that is my professional advice.

    The Sweet Life Bakery Ky / Etsy

    Get a pound from The Sweet Life Bakery Ky on Etsy for $10.

    23. A "sharing size" of PB M&Ms I'm going to need medically attached to my hand STAT.


    Get them from Target for $3.99.

    24. KIND peanut butter–filled chocolate bars that probably don't need any more intro. I would murder for their nut butter-filled bars. Just saying!


    Get them from Target for $4.19 (also check out the similar minis).

    25. Chew granola bars you might wanna keep on hand for hanger emergencies.


    Get an eight-pack from Target for $0.99.

    26. Scrumptious trail mix I'd rec buying in bulk for extremely obvious reasons.


    Get it from Target for $4.87.

    27. A trio of chocolate frogs because every time you watch ole Harry Potter, you think about how those *do* sound like the perfect Hogwarts Express snack.


    Get a three-pack from Mouth for $12.50.

    28. A lemur-themed cereal with a flavor combo you and I both can get behind.


    FYI, it's organic!

    Get it from Target for $3.69.

    29. White chocolate–covered peanuts (oh, and the peanuts are dipped in PB and THEN the white chocolate) in a gorgeous box that'll show it's also (at least a little) about presentation!

    Dylan's Candy Bar

    Get them from Dylan's Candy Bar for $20.

    30. And some scented slime to play with once your stash of Reese's cups runs dry.

    Bliss Balm / Etsy

    Get it from Bliss Balm on Etsy for $4.99+ (available in three sizes).

    Find the perfect gift for any occasion, from white elephant gift exchanges to gifts for teachers, housewarming gifts to birthday gifts, and even the perfect gift basket if you’re truly stumped. Plus, check out the BuzzFeed gift guide for even more incredible gifting ideas.

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form