Promising review: "I am terrible at doing at my eyeliner. I have a shaky hand, extremely little focus, and like to give up within two seconds of my makeup not looking magically perfect. So safe to say mastering liquid eyeliner was not on my to-do list — I just assumed I'd always have to live that smudged wing life. BUT THEN. The Double Take Eyeliner introduced itself, took my hand, and did all the work for me. The liquid tip is extra long with an angle that really helps you create straight lines without much thought at all (which is excellent, because I have the focus of a toddler). Plus, it never smudges, even if I rub my eyes which I do all the time, curse me. You can get it alone in deep black, which is a TRUE deep black, or get the trio kit like me to try out different colors (it comes with black, brown, and burgundy). They call them 'travel-size,' but they're pretty big to me and I haven't even run out yet. I used to stick with black eyeliner, but recently I'm hooked on their brown shade. It's deep enough to still look smoky and dare I say a little dramatic, but lighter so it's not as harsh on my super pale skin and blue eyes. I actually think it makes a *better* smoky effect, but if you're going for sharp cat-eyes, black is your pal." —Emma McAnaw, BuzzFeed Staff
Get it from Tarte Cosmetics for $24.