Black Women Make Over White Women To Be More Like Black Women In A New Reality Show

Lifetime’s Girlfriend Intervention premieres tonight, and the internet is already buzzing with criticism.

1. Lifetime is set to debut a new show called Girlfriend Intervention on Aug. 27. It’s a makeover show similar to Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, only this time, a group of black women makeover white women.


The cast is described in the show’s intro as “four black women taught to always have it together and tell you like it is.”

2. The makeover team consists of (from left to right) “beauty pro” Tracy Balan, “fashion maven” Tiffiny Dixon, “home/sanctuary guru” Nikki Chu, and “soul coach” Tanisha Thomas of Bad Girls Club fame.


The show is the brainchild of the production team World of Wonder, also credited with the creation of RuPaul’s Drag Race and Million Dollar Listing.

3. The description of the show on Lifetime’s website makes no mention of race, but the description on Lifetime’s press site reads:

Many black women carry themselves with a great deal of pride, style and, most importantly, self-confidence. Where does it come from and how can it be obtained? Who better to teach a woman how to get that sparkle in her eye and spring back in her step? Each week, Girlfriend Intervention follows a woman whose personal space and self-esteem are in desperate need of a major makeover and a life-giving dose of diva inspiration.

4. A teaser for the show opens with “soul coach” Tanisha Thomas saying: “Trapped inside of every white girl is a strong black woman waiting to bust out.”

Lifetime / Via

In the opening of the first episode, Thomas proclaims that their goal is to help their makeover subject “reclaim her inner strong black woman.”

5. The show is already drawing criticism for its handling and treatment of race.

I've said it before, the concept behind this new Lifetime show #GirlfriendIntervention is idiotic, and borderline racist. SMDH.

— Lady Creepy Feet O_o (@JaiSayWhat)

I'm not understanding the premise of "Girlfriend Intervention" - why can't it just be a makeover show w/o the racial tropes? Ugh

— Film Fatale (@FilmFatale_NYC)

Why can't it just be a show about BW giving makeovers? Instead they make WW rap and take African dance classes? #GirlfriendIntervention

— Every 28hrs. (@AyyThereDelilah)

Wait, "Girlfriend Intervention" is a real show? Not a funny skit about how to be the most racially offensive show ever?

— Anna R (@aremoose)

For Harriet, a website dedicated to discussing issues of black womanhood, refers to the show as “a regurgitation of another tired stereotype about Black women,” and Variety’s Brian Lowry says “building all these familiar makeover-show elements around a racial component simply breeds a lot of tone-deaf blather, including the various things that black women will or won’t do.”

The program is driven by a few worrisome moving parts: the reliance on the “strong black woman” stereotype, which sets an unattainable expectation of invincibility for black women; a harkening to the “magical negro,” a trope in which a black character’s sole purpose is to save or enhance the life of a white protagonist; and the idea that black and white women are inherently different and monolithic. These elements reaffirm the historical white fantasy of black servitude that has long permeated American popular culture, from Gone With The Wind to The Help.

11. The first episode, titled “Joanie Get Your Groove Back,” is full of absolutes that paint black women as infallibly confident and self-assured and white women as mousey, timid, and bland.


Included are statements like:

•”With Caucasian women, everybody’s afraid to say how they really feel.”

• “There is not a sister on this planet that will miss out on a red carpet event because she felt like she was too fat. Honey, that is a white girl problem if I ever heard one.”

• “No self-respecting black woman would ever hide herself in this if she wants to keep her black card.”

•”Unfortunately, my white girlfriends, if they are anything other than a size 2, they are nervous and scared.”

12. Cast members Tanisha Thomas and Tiffiny Dixon spoke to women’s interest site Bustle about the controversy.




Dixon said the way the show handles race is “kind of the antithesis” to the problem of race. “Finally,” she says, “we’re coming together, we’re embracing the fact that, you know what, I’m proud of my race, my culture. You’re proud of your culture. Let’s come together and merge and learn from each other.”

“I think the fact that they’re criticizing it shows more racism on their side than our side,” said Thomas. “The message is really universal. It’s about women empowerment, women everywhere, all colors of all shapes and sizes.”

13. But some, like well-known beauty blogger Patrice Yursik of Afrobella, question whether or not the race angle is necessary to provide that empowerment.

Mark Lyndersay

“My initial reaction is sadness and disappointment. Can’t there be a makeover show that features women of color that doesn’t traffic in stereotypes?” she told BuzzFeed. “Not every black woman is the same. We aren’t all sassy caricatures. We don’t all have the same sense of style, we don’t all see the world through the same lens. This show makes it seem like we do.”

14. An actress who auditioned for the show spoke to BuzzFeed about her experience on the condition of anonymity.


She shared that the casting called, in part, for “sassy African American women,” another stereotype that many black women dread. The following came “directly from casting”:

World of Wonder is teaming up with a Major Cable Network to produce a new, funny make over show for women. [EXPERT/HOSTS] We are currently casting our make over team of experts/hosts. We are looking for dynamic, funny, attractive, sassy African American women that have knowledge or specialize in beauty, fashion, lifestyle, interior design, life coaching, relationships, astrology, etc. The bigger the personality, the better!

16. She said that there was heavy emphasis put on “being real” that led her to believe there was a specific type of blackness they were looking for.


Asked about the audition process, the actress said:

It was really strange to be honest. It’s becoming more common to do Skype auditions/meetings, but it still doesn’t feel like an audition. They asked me all kinds of questions: How old is too old to shop at Forever 21? If an older woman gets dumped, how do you help her feel young again? It seemed like a bunch of quasi-offensive questions, but the end goal was to make a suburban clueless woman feel her best.

Another part of the audition was discussing how to be “real” with some of the show’s guests if they don’t like something we advise. “Real” was hella emphasized and I was asked to come up with bigger reactions to a woman saying she doesn’t want highlights. I’m not bitter, but I think they wanted me to be a more caricatured Black woman and tell her how it is with a z-shaped snap.

She also said there was “an insistence on being louder — essentially ‘blacker’ every time I answered a question … Also they kept saying, ‘Imagine it’s just you and your girlfriends giving advice,’ which felt like a deliberate, ‘talk like you’re not talking to a white lady’ demand.”

18. The actress was unaware of the exact premise of the show when she auditioned, and after seeing the teaser, she said she felt like she “dodged a bullet.”


“If I had known exactly what the point of the show was (which seems pretty clearly to harp on old stereotypes of a magical negro sorting out the busted wardrobe of some nondescript white ladies), I wouldn’t have even auditioned,” she said.

Check out more articles on!

  Your Reaction?

    Starting soon, you'll only be able to post a comment on BuzzFeed using a Facebook account or via our app. If you have questions or thoughts, email us here.


    Hot Buzz

    Devastated Widow Of Kansas Immigrant Shot Dead In Bar Asks, "Do We Belong?"

    Make A Salad And We’ll Tell You How Many People You’ve Slept With

    Now Buzzing