Skip To Content

    38 Random And Forced Storylines On TV Shows That Never, Ever, EVER Should've Happened

    Serena and Dan finding out they had a half brother on Gossip Girl was so pointless.

    We asked members of the BuzzFeed Community to tell us what storyline from a TV show was completely unnecessary. Here's what they had to say:

    Warning: This post contains mentions of sexual assault. 

    1. When Britta and Troy dated on Community.

    Britta holding Troy's hand as they sit on a couch

    "It just came out of nowhere, and they had no romantic chemistry. I understand it was a plot device to address Troy and Abed's codependency in their friendship, but it just felt so off."


    2. Hayley getting back with Dylan and then getting pregnant on Modern Family.

    Hayley looking freaked out during her sonogram appointment

    "No thanks! She had grown so much during the show, and it ruined her character's journey. She should have got together with Andy and that's it."


    3. Michael coming back after he had presumably died on Jane the Virgin.

    Jane looking at Michael in shock and Rafael explaining how his sister faked Michael's death
    The CW

    "He died, and it took so long for her to grieve and move on that bringing him back for like three episodes seemed forced."


    4. Spencer having an evil twin at the end of Pretty Little Liars.

    Spencer and her identical twin Alex standing next to each other in fear

    "The show after Mona was revealed as 'A' went steadily downhill, but the entire last season was unnecessary."


    5. Mr. Turner getting into a motorcycle accident on Boy Meets World.

    Sean sitting beside Mr. Turner who is in a hospital bed with casts on his arm and head

    "It was like a big deal for one episode and then not really mentioned again for the rest of the series."

    Megan Townsend

    6. Lily and Rufus meeting their son on Gossip Girl.

    Rufus and Lily talking to their son Scott
    The CW

    "He was never mentioned again. This storyline added nothing to the plot and didn’t help the characters to progress in any way."

    Pinkie pie

    7. Rachel and Joey’s romance on Friends.

    Ross walking in on Rachel and Joey kissing

    "It makes me cringe even now."


    8. Ben's whole existence on Friends.

    Rachel and Ben

    "The show could've done without him. There were other ways they could have incorporated Carol and Susan in the series without Ben, especially since they completely dropped Ben for the last two seasons."


    9. Quinn getting in a car accident and being in a wheelchair on Glee.

    Quinn in a wheelchair going up a ramp

    "They had her go through physical therapy with Joe, just for them to not even stay close at all. Then, by Nationals, she’s just up there dancing like nothing ever happened. Maybe they just needed something to stop Rachel and Finn from getting married, but that was legit ridiculous."


    10. When Blaine and Karofsky dated on Glee.

    Karofsky holding Blaine as they sit on the back of a truck

    Suggested by: ktparkins

    Karofsky was incredibly anti-gay and Kurt's biggest tormentor in high school. Kurt literally had to transfer schools one year because Karosky threatened to kill Kurt. So it's wild that Blaine could date someone who caused his ex so much trauma and fear.

    11. Eleven finding her siblings on Stranger Things.

    Eleven and Kali standing next to each other

    "It came out of nowhere and was so unnecessary and never mentioned following that episode."


    12. Archie dating his teacher Miss Grundy in the first season of Riverdale.

    Archie and Ms. Grundy about to kiss
    The CW

    "It was extremely random and had no significance to the show whatsoever."


    13. The whole Olivia kidnapping storyline on Scandal.

    Oliva Pope trying to escape from a window in a room

    "For me, that was when Scandal went to shit. You can clearly tell that the writers themselves were so confused with this storyline. They didn't know how to wrap it all up."


    14. When Finn kissed Emma soon before her wedding to Mr. Schue on Glee.

    Finn kissing Emma and her looking freaked out after

    "It wasn't even a love triangle. The storyline was just a mess and waste of episodes."


    15. Randy and Donna's relationship on That '70s Show.

    Donna and Randy talking

    "He pretty much disappeared in the last few episodes, didn't even show up in the series finale, and she still kissed Eric in the end anyway!"


    16. Cameron being in love with House on House.

    Cameron saying there's no point in working at the hospital if House isn't there and then kissing him

    "It just wasn’t genuine and made it seem like she was only there to fill the stereotypical female character role."


    17. Bryce's redemption arc on 13 Reasons Why.

    Ani defending Bryce and saying he was trying to become a better person

    Suggested by: 2025sarahc

    13 Reasons Why handled A LOT of — like, most — serious topics horribly. And one of their biggest mistakes in the third season was trying to get viewers to sympathize with Bryce and redeem his character despite the fact that he was a serial rapist.

    18. Debra getting over her stepbrother being a serial killer and realizing she had romantic feelings for him on Dexter.

    Debra confessing her feelings to Dexter

    "It was super out of the blue and never went anywhere except for giving me a creepy feeling, especially knowing that the actors were married at the time in real life."


    19. When Omar cheated on Ander with his sister's boyfriend on Elite.

    Ander telling Omar how chemo is scaring him and then Omar asking Malik to hook up at a party

    "It ruined an already tarnished relationship and made Omar seem like an actual fucking dick. Also, Malick served no purpose to the story whatsoever."


    20. Pam and Jim having marital problems in the final season of The Office.

    Jim and Pam walking together with annoyed expressions on their faces

    "It was unnecessary and felt completely ill timed. We spent nine seasons knowing they were soulmates, and then some camera guy throws them off for a second? Come on."


    21. Emma and Spinner getting married on Degrassi: The Next Generation.

    Spinner and Emma standing at the altar

    "Just why? They have literally no chemistry and no relationship development."

    Renata Vontobel

    22. Leo cheating on Grace on Will and Grace.

    Leo telling Will that he kissed someone else while he was in Cambodia

    "It was totally out of character for him. I don't see why Grace couldn't just be happily married and still be close to her friends."


    23. When Reagan was a replacement for Jess on New Girl.

    Reagan and Jess

    "I think Zooey Deschanel was on maternity leave or something, but I would have rather had to wait than to have her essentially replaced."


    24. Ian and Lip getting DNA tests done on Shameless and finding out Ian is not Frank’s son, but the son of one of Frank’s brothers.

    Lip and Ian being shocked by seeing Clayton, Frank's identical twin

    "They spend one episode looking for Frank’s brothers, make an assumption about Clayton being Ian’s dad, and then it’s never mentioned again."


    25. When Emma's stepdad, Mr. Simpson, cheated on her mom on Degrassi: The Next Generation.

    Emma catching Mr. Simpson kissing Ms. Hatzilakos in a movie theatre

    "He cheated with his boss, who was the vice principal. It was ridiculous and totally out of character for him. It was out of left field, went nowhere, and kind of ruined a good, wholesome character for literally no reason."


    26. When Schmidt cheated on Cece on New Girl.

    Schmidt talking about how he never broke up with Elizabeth to date Cece and how he feels terrible about it

    "It was the most unbelievable storyline in television. Period."


    27. Luke discovering he had a daughter on Gilmore Girls.

    Luke talking to April and processing that he's her father
    The WB

    "It didn't add anything; it was just time filling."


    28. Landry killing a guy on Friday Night Lights.

    Landry grabbing a blunt object and hitting a man's head with it

    "LITERALLY unnecessary because they proceeded to never mention it ever again."


    29. The tickling-videos storyline on Riverdale.

    Terry offering to film Kevin being tickled on film for money
    The CW

    "It just made me so uncomfortable; it was unnecessary and creepy. Kevin deserved better."

    That Emo Chick

    30. Izzie having a brain tumor that resulted in her having sex with her dead ghost boyfriend on Grey's Anatomy.

    Izzie having sex with the ghost of her dead ex-boyfriend, Denny

    31. Caleb and Spencer's relationship on Pretty Little Liars.

    Caleb and Spencer sitting on a couch, holding hands, and looking at a laptop

    "It didn’t really add anything to the show for me, and it was confusing to watch, knowing they were clearly going to end up with other people."


    32. Annie’s cousin staying with her family on 90210 and ruining Annie's social life for no reason.

    Annie confronting Emily and then attacking her
    The CW

    "I don’t even remember her name. It was so unnecessary."


    33. The whole last season of Once Upon a Time.

    Scene in a church from Once Upon a Time finale in which Regina is crowned "the Good Queen"

    "It was completely unnecessary and didn’t really make sense from the other seasons. Like, why would they introduce a whole new set of characters?"


    34. Tom finding out he had a daughter before he and Lynette were together on Desperate Housewives.

    Kayla looking out of the back window of a car at Tom and Lynette as she's driven away

    "They brought her and her horrible mom into the show to cause problems between Tom and Lynette, killed off her mom, made the daughter a huge brat to Lynette, then sent her away with her random grandparents, never to be spoken about again! I hated that storyline."


    35. On Glee, when Rachel gave up her dream Broadway role in Funny Girl to star in that really bad TV show that got canceled.

    Rachel in scene from TV show pilot that got canceled

    "While it was nice to see Rachel Berry finally fail at something and not have it fixed by a diva tantrum, the plot didn't make sense. The whole goal of her character was to be on Broadway, and she idolized Barbra Streisand. It ruined the show for me."


    36. The whole high school musical storyline in Season 1 of The Politician.

    Payton singing onstage and playing a guitar

    "Ryan Murphy was just looking for an excuse to have Ben Platt sing again."


    37. Frank being revealed as the child of Sam and Hannah's incestuous relationship on How to Get Away With Murder.

    Annalise telling Bonnie that Frank is the product of incest between Sam and Hannah

    "It was a little much. It was only placed in the last few episodes to try to wrap up some loose ends, but they could have done that a lot of other ways."


    38. And Ted going back to Robin on the series finale of How I Met Your Mother.

    Robin looking out her window to see Ted standing there with a french horn

    "You just spent an entire nine seasons waiting for him to find Tracy, and this devalues the love he and Tracy had before her death and how she’s everything he was looking for. It makes it feel like the whole point of the show was for him and Robin to be together, which it wasn’t. They wanted different things."


    Note: Some submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.

    What are other storylines on TV do you feel were unnecessary? Let us know in the comments!

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form