back to top
Food

Here's What Starbucks' Secret Menu Harry Potter Beverages Taste Like

Did these drinks manage their mischief?

Posted on

In case you didn't hear the good news, you can order not one, but TWO Harry Potter-themed drinks off of Starbucks' "secret menu."

Warner Bros.

Sorry to get all Hermione Granger on you, but "secret menu" is a bit of a misnomer...basically you can alter Starbucks beverages a million different ways. It's called customization, people!

Muggles, wizards, and witches alike can make a few ~custom tweaks~ to their favorite beverages and voila, you've transfigured ordinary Starbucks drinks into a Butterbeer Latte or Butterbeer Frappuccino.

Warner Bros.

Professor McGonagall approves.

Naturally, a few of us BuzzFeed wizards had to see how magical these beverages really where. So we used some Floo Powder* to get to our nearest Starbucks ASAP.

Warner Bros.

*JK, we walked.

First, we tried the Butterbeer Frappuccino.

For the Butterbeer Frappuccino, order a Crème Frappuccino. Add one pump each of toffee nut and caramel syrup, and finish the drink off with whipped cream and a caramel drizzle!
Sam Stryker

For the Butterbeer Frappuccino, order a Crème Frappuccino. Add one pump each of toffee nut and caramel syrup, and finish the drink off with whipped cream and a caramel drizzle!

Sam's Thoughts:

OK, I was pretty surprised by how much I enjoyed this treat. YES, it was pretty darn sweet — but not so sweet that I would have to go to Madam Pomfrey with cavities after enjoying one. It tasted pretty similar to the frozen Butterbeer which is served at Universal, which is basically canon. Five points to Gryffindor — or should I say, five points to Starbucks!Sam's Rating: 4/5 Broomsticks
Sam Stryker

OK, I was pretty surprised by how much I enjoyed this treat. YES, it was pretty darn sweet — but not so sweet that I would have to go to Madam Pomfrey with cavities after enjoying one. It tasted pretty similar to the frozen Butterbeer which is served at Universal, which is basically canon. Five points to Gryffindor — or should I say, five points to Starbucks!

Sam's Rating: 4/5 Broomsticks

Stephen's Thoughts:

Witches and wizards beware, this thing was SWEET. It's basically two cups of sugar and a dash of milk for good measure — it tastes like something you'd find at Sugarplum's Sweets Shop on Diagon Alley. If you've got a major sweet tooth, you'll be happy with this. Otherwise, you might wanna resign yourself to muggle life and order yourself a plain old coffee.Stephen's Rating: 2/5 Broomsticks
Stephen LaConte

Witches and wizards beware, this thing was SWEET. It's basically two cups of sugar and a dash of milk for good measure — it tastes like something you'd find at Sugarplum's Sweets Shop on Diagon Alley. If you've got a major sweet tooth, you'll be happy with this. Otherwise, you might wanna resign yourself to muggle life and order yourself a plain old coffee.

Stephen's Rating: 2/5 Broomsticks

Brian's thoughts:

I have to be honest, I wasn’t sure how much I’d enjoy this — I am not much of sweets person. When I took the first sip it felt like all of Honeydukes had exploded in my mouth (it was very sweet). But, to my surprise, after taking another few sips the sweetness seemed to mellow out, and I could really taste the salty caramel. Overall I enjoyed it, it reminded me a lot of the Butterbeer they sell at Universal. Brian’s rating: 3/5 Broomsticks
Brian Galindo

I have to be honest, I wasn’t sure how much I’d enjoy this — I am not much of sweets person. When I took the first sip it felt like all of Honeydukes had exploded in my mouth (it was very sweet). But, to my surprise, after taking another few sips the sweetness seemed to mellow out, and I could really taste the salty caramel. Overall I enjoyed it, it reminded me a lot of the Butterbeer they sell at Universal.

Brian’s rating: 3/5 Broomsticks

Next, we tried the Butterbeer Latte.

To order a Butterbeer Latte, order a latte with whole milk. Then add one pump each of caramel syrup, toffee nut syrup, and cinnamon dolce syrup. Finally, top the drink with whipped cream and salted caramel bits.
Sam Stryker

To order a Butterbeer Latte, order a latte with whole milk. Then add one pump each of caramel syrup, toffee nut syrup, and cinnamon dolce syrup. Finally, top the drink with whipped cream and salted caramel bits.

Sam's Thoughts:

I didn't enjoy this drink QUITE as much as I enjoyed the Butterbeer Frappuccino. It wasn't *quite* sweet enough to be a dessert, but not strong enough to count as a coffee (I like my coffee like the Forbidden Forest — dark, and also may cause you to shake with terror). But once I had a few sips, I realized the drink stood on its own merits. It's not GREAT, but not too bad either. Sam's Rating: 3/5 Broomsticks
Sam Stryker

I didn't enjoy this drink QUITE as much as I enjoyed the Butterbeer Frappuccino. It wasn't *quite* sweet enough to be a dessert, but not strong enough to count as a coffee (I like my coffee like the Forbidden Forest — dark, and also may cause you to shake with terror). But once I had a few sips, I realized the drink stood on its own merits. It's not GREAT, but not too bad either.

Sam's Rating: 3/5 Broomsticks

Stephen's Thoughts:

Lord knows I'm not exactly a coffee drinker, but I actually liked this one! The flavors were balanced quite nicely — just the right amount of sweetness to counter the bitterness of the coffee. I also liked that the drink was hot, since that's how I always pictured butterbeer when I read the books. Accio more of this shit, please.Stephen's Rating: 4.5/5 Broomsticks
Stephen LaConte

Lord knows I'm not exactly a coffee drinker, but I actually liked this one! The flavors were balanced quite nicely — just the right amount of sweetness to counter the bitterness of the coffee. I also liked that the drink was hot, since that's how I always pictured butterbeer when I read the books. Accio more of this shit, please.

Stephen's Rating: 4.5/5 Broomsticks

Brian's thoughts:

I really enjoyed this drink. For me it struck the perfect balance between being sweet and bitter. It’s a (hot) drink I can imagine sipping on a rainy night, while sitting on a comfy couch in front of the fireplace in the common room. This is the perfect concoction and, best of all, it won’t have you later taking a trip to Diagon Alley to find a dentist. Brian’s rating: 4.5/5 Broomsticks
Brian Galindo

I really enjoyed this drink. For me it struck the perfect balance between being sweet and bitter. It’s a (hot) drink I can imagine sipping on a rainy night, while sitting on a comfy couch in front of the fireplace in the common room. This is the perfect concoction and, best of all, it won’t have you later taking a trip to Diagon Alley to find a dentist.

Brian’s rating: 4.5/5 Broomsticks

So there you have it! Now grab your broomsticks and fly on down to your nearest Starbucks — we want to hear what YOU have to think!

Warner Bros.
  1. If you've tried these drinks, what do you think?

    If you've tried these drinks, what do you think?
    Correct
    Incorrect
    Love them both!
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I only liked the Butterbeer Frappuccino
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I only liked the Butterbeer Latte
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I didn't like either, to be honest!<br />
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later
Looks like we are having a problem on the server.
If you've tried these drinks, what do you think?
  1.  
    vote votes
  2.  
    vote votes
  3.  
    vote votes
  4.  
    vote votes
Take quizzes and chill with the BuzzFeed app.