We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.
1.A tin recipe box with cards for safeguarding the recipe for their famous homemade rugelach (that you'll definitely be smuggling a dozen of in your bag on the way out).
3.A throw blanket that will turn any corner of her home into The Official Snuggle Corner.
4.A wine decanter to enhance their already excellent wine game. Decanters really do make a difference. I dated a sommelier for a week once. I would know.
5.A set of aesthetically pleasing geometric coasters you can configure a ton of different ways to make coffee table protection more stylish than ever before.
6.A Jacobson Salt gift set because salt is god's greatest gift to mortals and, in my opinion, the greatest gift you can give to another person.
7.A set of whiskey stones to make sure your relationship with the hostess isn't ~on the rocks~. Just pop them into the freezer, add to a drink, and enjoy at your leisure — without worrying about it getting watered down by ice!
8.The Voting Game, a card game that makes fun out of intimately knowing your friends' personalities. My friends and I call this "The Friendship Ender," but I think that's an us problem. What's a party without a little ~drama~?
9.A bar of Ritual Chocolate, the most delicious chocolate in the game. All bars are handcrafted, so I'm pretty sure you can call this a "handmade gift" and get away with it.
10.A copy of BuzzFeed's Tasty Latest & Greatest Cookbook, which is choc-full of delicious party recipes such as carne asada fries and sliders four ways! Get. In. My. Belly.
11.A customizable light box for a perfect party decoration as well as quirky everyday decor. Mine would say "Casper's #1 Fan."
12.A cotton cross-back apron because 100% of hostesses want to look like they work in the Bon Appetit test kitchen. That's just a fact! Also it has pockets!
13.A Capri Blue Volcano candle so you can have *NEWS FLASH* the candle they burn in Anthropologie, the greatest smelling place on planet earth!!! THAT'S a gift that keeps on giving.
14.A set of wine glass markers because without them, guests will become befuddled and unable to figure out whose wine is whose. There are many, MANY problems in the world, but this is one we can actually fix!
15.A stringed photo display for them to curate their own tiny museum of the party mems. Remember when Sheryl dropped all that potato salad? With a photo strung up proud, we'll never forget!
16.A beau-tea-ful tin of Harney & Sons tea so the host-in-chief can relax after all the hubub of another successful fête.
17.A pack of biodegradable paper straws whose cuteness and biodegradability will have party guests and sea-turtles equally thrilled!
18.A Bali Soap gift set so everyone's hands can smell fresh as can be after digging into a vat of buffalo chicken dip (the only good dip, fight me).
19.A Homesick candle that will make the home you were warmly invited to even warmer and more inviting.