Jim Halpert as Aladdin
Because they're both mischievous, good-hearted, and super hot.
Pam Beesly as Belle
A little quiet, mysterious, and smart as a whip.
Michael Scott as the Mad Hatter
Because they are both quite possibly insane.
Dwight Schrute as Cogsworth
Dwight and Cogsworth both like rules and order.
Stanley Hudson as The Caterpillar
Slow talking and no nonsense from these two.
Phyllis Lapin-Vance As Mrs. Potts
Phyllis is sweet and nurturing just like Mrs. Potts.
Kelly Kapoor as Tinker Bell
Both prone to jealous fits.
Angela Martin as The Evil Queen
As they both know how to give the best icy stares.
And Creed Bratton as Ariel
Creed and Ariel are both beautiful creatures who came from the sea.