Skip To Content

    Start Replenishing Your Expired Makeup Collection With These 33 Beauty Products

    I know how much you love that one lipstick, but it's been three years and you've gotta make like Elsa and let it go.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. Ownest Cosmetics eyebrow soap, a must-have for anyone (like myself) with unruly brows that seem to have a mind of their own. This will add the texture and thickness you've been looking for.

    the two packs of eyebrow soap and spoolie brushes
    a reviewer showing off their perfectly manicured eyebrows

    Promising review: "The product works well and gives you a defined and natural-looking brow. Easy to shape and design my eyebrows. Sets the brows in place! It's not sticky and doesn't dry hard. I can't live without it anymore and will repurchase again!" —Trevor gorman

    Get a set of two from Amazon for $7.99.

    2. E.l.f Cosmetics Mint Melt Cooling Face Primer, complete with hyaluronic acid, antioxidants, and a soothing gel texture you'll love because it'll keep your makeup in place while also delivering a cooling sensation — perfect for those hot summer days.

    four tubes of the light green mint cooling primer
    E.l.f. Cosmetics

    Promising review: "I have an extremely oily nose and no coverage left after a long day wearing a mask. This primer gripped my foundation so well that it stayed in place all day under my mask and I still looked flawless after a hot yoga class...with a mask...for an hour! Controls my oils too. I’m in love!" —Laurengirl

    Get it from E.l.f Cosmetics for $8

    3. Ilia Beauty liquid highlighter to make it seem like you've spent the *perfect* amount of time baking in the golden sun (except we both know you haven't seen daylight in a week).

    a gif of a model applying the shimmery lotion to her hand
    the pump bottle of the product
    Ilia Beauty

    Promising review: "I'm not much of a makeup person, but saw this on Instagram and really wanted to try it. I've been mixing this every day with a very light tinted foundation and my skin now has the PRETTIEST glow. I actually get compliments when I go out which is nice. My cousin and two aunts bought a bottle after seeing my illuminated complexion. I use the color Nova, it has just a tiny touch of bronze which allows me to use it all over my face with out looking like I'm wearing makeup. Good stuff! I'm absolutely loving my glow!" —Stephanie P.

    Get it from Ilia Beauty for $42 (available in three shades).

    4. Elizabeth Mott waterproof eyeshadow primer to keep your carefully blended eyeshadow in place — you'll be thanking me for this one later, trust me.

    the pink tube that says
    a reviewer showing how their eyeshadow stayed in place from 3pm to 11pm
    @elizabethmott / Via www.instagram.com, www.amazon.com

    Promising review: "So let me start by saying I have used nearly every eyeshadow primer available. From high end to low...they don't hold a candle to Thank Me Later. I have very oily skin. Using this primer, shadow lasts a full eight hours or more. I could get maybe five or six out of the other brands if I was lucky. I got this as a sample in my Ipsy bag, and I had to buy the full-size product straight away! I couldn't be happier with my purchase. Thank you, Elizabeth Mott, for finally making a primer that lasts! I love this stuff!" —Melissa Mae

    Get it from Amazon for $13.48.

    5. Etude House mineral powder that'll help anyone with oily skin get through the day without feeling like they have to blot at their face sporadically to keep their makeup in place. 

    Promising review: "I have SUPER oily skin. I have tried many, many things from diet changes to new skincare regimens, and am consistently left with skin that still feels quite greasy by the end of the day. I absolutely LOVE this powder. It is lightweight, super sheer, and works very well at keeping a matte appearance on my face. I generally only need to reapply once, halfway through the day, after a quick refresher with a wipe. I haven't noticed it causing any breakouts (unlike some other powders I've tried before), and it doesn't leave an ashy look to my complexion, even when I accidentally over powder an area. I am going to order some more!" —Dawn

    Get it from Amazon for $5.93.

    6. Benefit Cosmetics Porefessional Super Setter spray you can use to both secure your makeup *and* help blur your pores for up to 16 hours.

    the blue setting spray
    a model showing their skin before and after using the spray
    Sephora

    Promising review: "I have used multiple setting sprays in the past but this one is by far the best. The spray is not sticky and the mist is very fine and feels greats on my face. I would 10/10 recommend to anyone looking for a new setting spray and anyone who wants their makeup to last all day — even under a mask!" —KCris406

    Get it from Sephora for $32.

    7. Or NYX matte finish setting spray that'll make sure the hour you spent perfectly applying primer, concealer, and highlighter doesn't go to waste.

    a reviewer with freshly applied makeup
    the same reviewer with their makeup still on perfectly 5 hours later

    This spray has a matte formula, meaning it won't turn your makeup into a greasy or oily mess.

    Promising review: "This spray is everything! Like, oh my gosh. I notice the difference if I forget to spray this on. I've walked through the humid city of New Orleans in the middle of July and my makeup stayed on from the time I got to work and was mostly still there by the time I got home, which was nine hours later. I can't rave enough about this, and I'm very picky when it comes to makeup." —missyj95

    Get it from Amazon for $7.

    8. A set of five Kulfi Beauty highly-pigmented eyeliners featuring an ultra-creamy formula (I see you aloe vera extract and vitamin E) that'll stay in place for the entire eye. Anyone feel like applying a cat eye right about meow?

    the five underlined eyeliners standing up against an ombre pink background
    close up of a model with black eyeliner around her eyes
    Kulfi Beauty

    Kulfi Beauty, named after a type of South Asian ice cream, is a South Asian-owned business that makes products that celebrate and empower the diverse needs of their communities.

    Promising review: "These are just what I have searched a decade for. I've never had an eyeliner go on so smooth or effortlessly before. The color stays vibrant all day, not sinking into my skin or transferring elsewhere. I am in love with this product." —Andrea J

    Get them from Kulfi Beauty for $85.

    9. Vivienne Sabó Paris clump-free mascara with a lightweight and long-lasting formula that'll have people asking if you recently got eyelash extensions. Joke's on them!

    a reviewer's before and after photos with and without the mascara
    the mascara

    Promising review: "I absolutely LOVE this mascara. I have very sensitive eyes and am highly devoted to my trusted brands. When a friend suggested this mascara I was curious, as she loved it. For the price point and how good it looked on her eyes, I thought why not. Holy moly. I'm in love. It makes my lashes longer — looks like I'm natural but better — and has a thinner formula so it looks like I have a billion gorgeous lashes, and looks the same all day long. I cannot recommend this enough. It doesn't rub during the day and give me that black-eye look. It's wonderful. Must buy." —Katherine Ochsman

    Get it from Amazon for $12.95 (available in three colors).

    10. Or Essence Lash Princess mascara, a must-have for anyone with a flair for the *dramatics* in both their day-to-day life and their makeup.

    a reviewer holding the black tube of mascara
    a reviewer's long black eyelashes

    Promising review: "After using Lights, Camera, Lashes by Tarte for the past year, I got tired of breaking the bank over mascara. My sister suggested Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect and I IMMEDIATELY fell in love. It provides dramatic length and great volume. I can honestly say I can’t stop looking at my eyelashes in the mirror every single day because of how awesome they look. Also, it is very long-wearing. I go from an eight-hour work day right to the gym and sweat like crazy...and this stuff doesn’t budge! I love it!!" —Carrie E Miller

    Get it from Amazon for $4.99.

    11. Ilia Beauty Liquid Powder Chromatic Eye Tint you'll surely be amazed by as it goes on as a liquid but dries as a powder, leaving you with flawless eye makeup.

    a model with subtle gold eyeshadow on
    a bunch of liquid eyeshadow tubes
    Ilia Beauty

    Promising review: "I love the subtleness of the color and how it stays put. Feels gentle on the skin." —Alba R.

    Get it from Ilia Beauty for $28 (available in five shades).

    12. Fluide's Otherworldly Pride Collection, which contains an eight-pan makeup palette starring an array of sparkly colors, a T-shirt, a set of face gems, and a coppery gloss you can use on your lips, lids, or face.

    the products from the collection
    two models holding up the makeup palette
    Fluide

    10% of all sales of this collection will be donated to mutual aid platform For Our Sibs. Fluide is a queer-owned small business based in Brooklyn, NY that sells gorgeous makeup.

    Get it from Fluide for $50 (shirt available in unisex sizes S–3XL).

    13. Maybelline Instant Age Rewind concealer to brighten your under-eyes and help you disguise the fact your Sunday Scaries kept you up way past your bedtime.

    a buzzfeed editor holding the concealer stick
    a gif of a buzzfeed editor applying the concealer under her eyes
    Kayla Suazo / BuzzFeed

    Promising review: "I am a makeup snob. I have stupidly high standards for cosmetic performance, and drugstore brands have let me down every single time I've given them a shot. So when I graduated from Covergirl to Sephora after college, I never looked back. My kit is full of Dior and YSL foundation, Armani concealer, Benefit brighteners, etc. But this thing is truly great. The sponge applicator is better than you think. Firstly, it's antimicrobial, so you don't have to worry about the hygiene aspect. Secondly, its ability to blend the product is outstanding. The concealer itself doubles as a highlighter, it looks good without primer, and it lasts so much longer than you'd expect." —Sarita

    Get it from Amazon for $5.86+ (available in 18 shades).

    Check out our full review of Maybelline Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer.

    14. Lovoir winged eyeliner stamp if you obsess over makeup tutorials but haven't been able to nail liquid eyeliner just yet.

    a model holding the black pen with the slanted eyeliner stamp on the end
    a reviewer showing how easy their cat eye came out with the tool

    Promising review: "Let me start by saying this isn't my first cat-eye rodeo. I've tried the taping method, normal liquid liner, plastic winged stamping devices, stencils, all of it! Well, this gem arrived and I immediately had to try it out, all while laughing at how terrible this would probably turn out...but to my surprise I put the left cat-eye on first and it was perfect. I thought this was a fluke and did the right eye...again, it came out clean and perfect! I HAVE NEVER IN MY LIFE BEEN ABLE TO DO A CAT-EYE IN UNDER 10 MINUTES, LET ALONE THE TWO MINUTES THIS TOOK TO DO! There were no sloppy streaks that I had to touch up or anything you would expect. Just a clean crisp line. I can now do a cat-eye EVERY day and look/feel like a badass. Everyone can think I spend hours doing my makeup in the morning." —LadyMeow

    Get a set of two from Amazon for $14.97 (available in two sizes and colors)

    15. A playful BH Cosmetics eyeshadow palette you can use to create so many ~groovy~ looks you won't know where to start! It includes an array of matte finishes and shimmers to mix and match.

    a flower power themed eyeshadow palette with 16 different colors
    BH Cosmetics

    Promising review: "Very good pigmentation and loved the colors!" —Stephanie F.

    Get it from BH Cosmetics for $12.

    16. Winky Lux flower balm you'll find simply magical when it goes on clear, then blossoms into the perfect shade of pink as it combines with your natural pH level. In addition to its lovely color, it'll keep you lips feeling fresh and hydrated.

    a gif of a model putting the lip balm on
    a model applying the lip balm on which is clear with a tiny flower inside
    Winky Lux

    My sister and I have this fun lil' lip balm, and we love it! The flower inside is as pretty as the shade of pink it creates. I like minimal makeup, so this product has been a slam dunk for me. My lips are *always* chapped (also I tend to chew on them, so that's on me) and this has been a solid solution to keeping them hydrated and looking cute.

    Promising review: "This is the best for moisturizing your lips and it gives you a little hint of color. It has the prettiest flower 🌹 inside the lipstick itself. I really appreciate the look. It’s not overwhelming in terms of tint and it really doesn’t have an overpowering scent. I will definitely buy again." —MC Joseph

    Get it from Amazon for $16 (available in three flower colors).

    17. Or AJ Crimson metallic lipstick in a sultry wine color, in case you're looking for a way to add a bold pop of color into your look.

    a model wearing a sparkly red lip
    AJ Crimson

    AJ Crimson is a Black-owned small business that sells vegan, cruelty-free makeup.

    Get it from AJ Crimson for $22.

    18. A revolutionary Ciaté London lip shadow starring the iconic Edna Mode you'll be able to build up into the pigment you prefer most while appreciating it's lighter-than-air formula.

    the editor showing their subtle lip color while holding up the product
    a pink square lip powder with edna mode on the front of the package
    Heather Braga / BuzzFeed, Ciaté London

    I'm a diehard Disney fan (a Disney adult, if you will) and was so excited when Ciaté London announced they'd be releasing a collection all about Edna Mode. I was gifted the entire set (squeeeeeeealing still!) but was the most impressed with this lip shadow. I had never tried a product like this (Ciaté London has an array of colors that aren't Disney-inspired) and right off the bat am extremely impressed. It's really easy to layer on the color and build it up so it's more pigmented, but I love that you can also go lighter with it and make it look like a subtle lip tint. It feels like air on my lips — like I don't have product on at all! This will 100% be my go-to travel lip product. You'll have a hard time convincing me that the brilliant Edna Mode didn't actually develop this herself.

    Get it from Ciaté London for $20.

    19. KKW Beauty crème lipstick or subtle blush  that'll convince everyone you have a glam squad just like Kris, Kim, Kourtney, Khloe, Kendall, and Kylie.

    four different pink lipsticks
    blush
    Ulta, Joyce Park

    I'd consider myself a connoisseur of Kardashian products (truly, you don't want to know how much makeup I've bought between KKW Beauty and Kylie Cosmetics) so I can *promise* your pal won't be disappointed by anything you snag from the brand. I personally love Kim's blushes and lipsticks as they're always nice neutral colors that can be used all year long.

    Get the lipstick from Ulta for $18 (available in six shades) and the blush from KKW Beauty for $18 (available in three shades).

    20. Sacha setting powder to provide you with shine-free coverage allllllll day long and keep that makeup you carefully applied lookin' flawless.

    Promising review: "As a YouTube beauty-channels addict, I've learned to use Sacha Buttercup powder by packing on the product using a mini BeautyBlender on all the areas where I get super oily: under my eyes down to my cheeks, on my forehead between my brows, on the bridge of my nose, and on the front of my chin. I let it sit for about five minutes and then I dust it off with a large fluffy foundation brush. That is the process that I use and based on my experience, I give the product five stars. I have MAJOR oily skin and my makeup lasts all day without melting off (it used to literally slide off before I met Sacha Buttercup). I can blot during the day with sheets when I start feeling oily (despite the fact I don't look oily) and it still functions." —Islas Virgenes

    Get it from Amazon for $29 (available in two colors).

    21. Latorice dip powder kit you can use to save TONS of dollars on fancy manis without giving up the joy you feel after getting a long lasting, high-quality manicure.

    Reviewer with black sparkly nails
    Reviewer with periwinkle nails and glittery white accent nail and thumb nail

    It comes with a base coat, an activator, a top coat, five color powders, a nail file, a brush, and instructions.

    Promising review: "This product is great! As someone who is CONSTANTLY getting their nails done (dipping powder) at salons, it has been hard to do so because of COVID-19. I was looking for an inexpensive kit with neutral colors that I could use. This starter kit has been an absolute lifesaver during these unprecedented times. It is so easy to use! I finished off my nails with a gel top coat and cured it under the UV light that I had from a while ago (I attached a photo on the right). Overall it's an amazing product — very satisfied!" —Amazon Customer

    Get it from Amazon for $15.98.

    </