He will continue to be a little creep, but that won't stop us from tuning in and being fascinated and horrified by him in equal measure.
Here's everything we know so far about the upcoming season:
🚨SPOILER WARNING🚨 for the Seasons 1-3 of You.
New city, same creepy, murderous Joe.
🚨SPOILER WARNING🚨 for the Seasons 1-3 of You.
"The tone is similar but it's shifting in that there is a different format. We're using a different format," he said to ET. "It's almost like we're shifting the genre slightly. And I think it works."
This could just be referring Joe's new stalker, but it could also have to do with the fact that the longer he remains at large, the more chances there are for his past to catch up with him.
It wouldn't be entirely surprising if the stalker was Marienne, since she's one of the only characters who knows about Joe's previous life and hasn't been killed by him. She's also onto him after Love's warning at the end of Season 3.
Penn could also be referring to Joe/Jonathan's relationship to Kate, which seems like it might have an enemies-to-lovers dynamic that the show hasn't seen before.
There's also Ellie (Jenna Ortega) from Season 2, who knows Joe killed Henderson and had something to do with Delilah's disappearance. Joe was sending her money throughout Season 3, but it's unclear how he'll keep doing that now that he's supposedly dead.
"That's going to be an ongoing conversation, because no, you can't pretend something that huge about a character didn't happen," Gamble said. "I think it will shape him from this moment forward."