back to top
TVAndMovies

This "Beauty And The Beast" Theory Perfectly Explains THAT Plot Hole

"Ev'ry day...like the one before."

Posted on

If you've seen the live-action Beauty and the Beast, then you probably know a) it's a pretty solid homage to the animated film, and b) it also has a few new ~twists~. Although, fair warning...

Crystal Ro / BuzzFeed / Disney

Okay, so let's talk about one of the big changes in the new film — the reveal at the end that some of the villagers are actually long lost family members of servants in the Beast's castle.

Like Mr. Potts (above) and Cogsworth's wife!
Crystal Ro / BuzzFeed / DIsney

Like Mr. Potts (above) and Cogsworth's wife!

Now, according to the film, it's been MANY years since the curse was originally cast. And while we know the Beast and the servants didn't age (e.g. Chip is still a child when he turns back to human form), it seems like kind of a plot hole that the villagers appear to be as young as their cursed family members.

Disney

That is, unless, you believe this clever theory from Redditor Hainted:

"The village of Villaneuve is caught in the Enchantress' curse as well. It's stated outright that she erased the memories of the Prince, his lands, and servants from the villagers' minds, but if you pay attention she also locked the village in a time loop."

TL;DR — THE VILLAGE IS CURSED IN A TIME LOOP!

Disney

And here are a few other good points to the theory:

During Belle's "Little Town" song she knows everyone's daily routine perfectly and is bored by all the predictability in town because it literally is the same.

Heck, she even sings, "Ev'ry morning just the same, since the morning that we came."
Disney

Heck, she even sings, "Ev'ry morning just the same, since the morning that we came."

Speaking of Belle and Maurice, they're exempt from the time loop because they moved into town after the curse was set.

Which could be another reason why the villagers think they're "odd."
Laurie Sparham / Disney

Which could be another reason why the villagers think they're "odd."

And the enchantress stayed in the village all these years under the guise of local spinster Agathe JUST to maintain her spell on them!

Makes sense, right?
Disney

Makes sense, right?

This time loop theory is definitely new and a bit alarming, but I have to admit, it's still pretty cool.

Disney
  1. So, what do you think? Does this theory makes sense?

    Correct
    Incorrect
    Yes, it makes so much sense!
    Correct
    Incorrect
    Nah, this is crazy talk.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later
Looks like we are having a problem on the server.
So, what do you think? Does this theory makes sense?
  1.  
    vote votes
    Yes, it makes so much sense!
  2.  
    vote votes
    Nah, this is crazy talk.
Take quizzes and chill with the BuzzFeed app.