HBO's landmark superhero series won several awards, including 11 Primetime Emmys, in just one season. Regina King and Yahya Abdul-Matten II are among the cast who won well-deserved Emmys, but the performance that went unnoticed at these awards was that of Tim Blake Nelson as Looking Glass. This bizarre character was recognized for his reflective mask and dry, sardonic wit. However, his struggles with loneliness and paranoia following the traumatic 11/2 Psychic Shockwave made him a character that you couldn't help but find relatable.