Skip To Content

    The Top 20 Performances From "Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist" So Far, Ranked

    "So bye-bye, Miss American Pie."

    If you've watched Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist, you'll know how hard the show can hit you in the feelings with its pop song covers.

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    It's like Glee, except it's situated in the tech world and everyone plays nice (except for the occasional Joan and Leif shenanigan).

    Between all the suave dance moves and emotive belts, the show never skimps on its beautifully produced musical numbers.

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    In honor of all the joy that Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist has given us, let's revisit and rank the show's best performances so far!

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    20. When Emily did a hilarious rendition of Bell Biv Devoe's "Poison."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    We just knew that her sister Jenna was going to be big trouble.

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 2

    19. When Zoey saw everyone dancing to Sixpence None the Richer's "Kiss Me."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    OK, so this performance hits on Zoey's fear of being unwanted and alone on her 30th birthday. Still, it's a cute, romantic moment for everyone else, and the best part is when Mo and Perry express their gushy feelings for each other!

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 7

    18. When Zoey had a dream about performing the Kiki Dee Band's "I've Got the Music in Me."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    We love a cast performance! This go-get-'em number really sets the show's tone alongside "Help!"

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 2

    17. When Mitch sang Cyndi Lauper's "True Colors" to Zoey.

    Mitch singing
    NBC

    The choreography is relatively simple compared with the show's flashier moments, but Mitch's stripped-down singing will destroy you emotionally.

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 1

    16. When Zoey and Max both sang Kelly Clarkson's "A Moment Like This" as they hooked up.

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Max tries to tune things out with "Take Me Out to the Ball Game" so that Zoey won't get a heart song from him when they hook up. But they end up dueting "A Moment Like This," and it's so sweet!

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 2

    15. When Abigail and her colleagues signed Rachel Platten's "Fight Song."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist always pushes boundaries, and this exceptional sign language performance of "Fight Song" just goes to show the series' creativity.

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 9

    14. When Zoey got ambushed with a crowd singing the Beatles' "Help!"

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    It's truly a great start to the show!

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 1

    13. When Zoey, Aiden, and Danny Michael Davis performed Nicki Minaj's "Starship" while incredibly high.

    Aiden, Zoey, and Danny Michael Davis dancing
    NBC / Via nbc.com

    It's really not that deep, but it's so, so very funny.

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 5

    12. When Emily sang the Pretenders' "I'll Stand by You" to David.

    Emily, David, and Miles
    NBC

    Emily is nervous about David wanting to leave his job, but she promises that she'll stand by him no matter what. You never know when Alice Lee will make you laugh or cry on this show!

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 4

    11. When Simon and Mo celebrated Simon's small victory at work with Janelle Monáe's "Tightrope."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Simon + Mo = DYNAMITE! (Speaking of, I'm very curious about when they'll do that BTS song on the show...)

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 6

    10. When Zoey performed Gnarls Barkley's "Crazy."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    It's a blast to see Zoey perform a heart song, which doesn't happen all that often in the first season. She only does so when she's in a funk (or very high), so Jane Levy always puts her all into these rare performances.

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 8

    9. When Max performed Shawn Mendes' "If I Can't Have You" to Zoey.

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Mall flash mobs can be a lot IRL, but we'll make an exception for Max.

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 7

    8. When Joan and Ava each staked their claim over Max with Brandy and Monica's "The Boy Is Mine."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    It's the Lauren Graham and Renée Elise Goldsberry duet we never knew we needed!

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 10

    7. When Simon was feeling himself while performing Lizzo's "Juice."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Off the high of crushing it as the new company spokesperson, Simon is *really* happy. John Clarence Stewart just charms effortlessly.

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 4

    6. When Mo dramatically sang Sam Smith's "Too Good at Goodbyes."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Mo always delivers when it comes to an emotional performance!

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 2

    5. When David expressed his feelings in court through Queen's "I Want to Break Free."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    It's really refreshing to see David loosen up and express how much he loves his son!

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 4

    4. When Max vented his frustration with his dad through Linkin Park's "Numb."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    We know that Skylar Astin can hit those notes, but his commitment to the emotional dancing and gesturing is something else!

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 5

    3. When Max made Zoey all flustered with his version of the Jonas Brothers' "Sucker."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Astin didn't have to go this hard, but he did it anyway. His vocals and dance moves are very smooth, but we're never going to forget how he seductively unzipped his jacket!

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 2

    2. When Simon performed Nina Simone's' "Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood."

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    Given the show's goofy, feel-good tone, this performance could have veered into "hammy" territory, but Stewart pulls it off smoothly while maintaining the gravity of the situation — tackling the racism at SPRQ Point.

    Which episode it's in: Season 2, Episode 5

    1. When the cast sang Don McLean's "American Pie" at Mitch's wake.

    NBC / Via giphy.com

    On top of the moment already being inherently upsetting, everyone is on their A game vocally to really emotionally eviscerate us. Levy is devastating with her tearful a cappella singing during the last few lines.

    Which episode it's in: Season 1, Episode 12

    Which performance from Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist gets you feeling some type of way? Let us know in the comments section!

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form