We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
1. A spoon you can personalize with your own name for when you're eating peanut butter in the best possible way — by the spoonful, of course.
2. The Spatty — a two-piece set of flexible, tiny spatulas to ensure every last bit of peanut butter in the jar ends up in your tummy, and not the garbage.
3. A book filled with hundreds of delicious ways to put the good stuff to use — we're talking recipes like peanut butter cheesecake, peanut butter waffles, and peanut noodles, just to name a few.
4. A pullover sweater to rock with whoever is the jelly to your PB. Whether it be your BFF, a sibling, your significant other, or hey, maybe you just want both of these because you're your own best friend — it's the yummiest way to stay cozy with your loved one.
5. A 10-pack of squeezable peanut butter. You may already be familiar with and love the RX Bars, and now they make peanut butter! There's something so satisfying about reading the ingredients of your snack when they're printed right on the front of the packaging, ya know?
6. And if squeeze packs aren't your thing, a pack of to-go cups is perfect making a sandwich, or dipping fruits/veggies/pretzels into wherever you are!
7. A peanut butter mixer that'll make stirring the separated oils so much easier. Keep buying your fave natural varieties with ease.
8. A tee to share a simple fact about yourself with others in the most efficient way possible. Anyone who dares to tell you that peanut butter isn't a food group may no longer exist in your life, sorry, I don't make the rules.
9. A peanut butter sampler filled with six small-batch blends for gifting the fellow PB lover in your life, or you know, just treating yourself.
10. A box of Perfect Bars — I cannot say enough good things about these, the peanut butter varieties SPECIFICALLY. They're PACKED with protein and somehow taste like peanut butter cookie dough. THEY'RE SO YUMMY.
11. An enamel pin so you can make sure you're always repping the good stuff in the trendiest way possible.
12. A variety pack of Reese's candy — this thing is full of peanut butter cups in different flavors and sizes, the beloved pieces, and sticks. I'm already salivating.
13. Or, if you're looking for something a little ~different,~ there's this pack of gourmet peanut and nut butter cups to give your tastebuds a unique treat.
14. And then of course, there's the option to buy a candy mold and make your own peanut butter cups right from the comfort of your own home! The only rule is that you're required to send me some! 🤷
15. A 12-pack of peanut butter-filled Clif bars perfect for keeping on-hand whenever hunger strikes between meals and you need a pick-me-up to hold you over.
16. An adorable pair of socks I can almost guarantee you'll make an effort to NEVER mismatch. Look at the little heart keeping them together. You're obligated, by law, to never separate these cuties.
17. A 30-pack of peanut butter pill pockets to make pill time for your very good fluffer a bit easier and a lot yummier.
18. And while we're on the subject of making your excellent pupperino's life easier, you should get them a Bath Buddy you simply stick to the shower/bath wall and slather with some peanut butter. It keeps them happy and distracted while you bathe them. Trust me, it'll make your life easier as well.
19. A baker's dozen of delicious peanut butter cookies that'll make your PB-loving heart and tummy very, very happy.
20. A throw pillow case to help you decorate your living space with a statement on the only acceptable way of eating peanut butter.
21. A pair of PB2 powdered peanut butter you can use in a variety of recipes: from baked goods to smoothies, or as a dip with fruit, or on some bread with jelly, or just plain — simply mix it with water first if you're eating as-is.
22. Peanut butter knives made specifically to help you stir your PB and scrape the jar clean — because we all know how annoying it is when there are those little bits left that you just can't seem to get.
23. A bag of peanut butter crunch ground coffee that'll seriously step up your morning cup of java. Anyone who tells you you're taking your obsession too far with flavored coffee is just a h8er.
24. And finally, a jar of the WORLD'S BEST PEANUT BUTTER — don't @ me on this one. When all else fails, there is nothing like twisting off the lid, peeling back the seal, and digging your spoon into a big ole' jar of natural creamy Skippy, which is what I'm gonna do right now. ✌️
We love you, peanut butter. <3
Looking for more great Amazon finds? Check out some of our favorite cheap things to buy on Amazon, some of the weirdest things on Amazon you might actually want, or read through all the rest of our incredible Amazon product recommendations.
Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!
