Skip To Content
  • Viral badge

33 TV Shows That Were Canceled Right When They Got Good

*Cries while rewatching The Society*

We recently asked the BuzzFeed Community to share the TV shows they thought got canceled way too soon and they did not disappoint! Here's what they said:

1. The Society (2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"It was renewed for a second season and then was later canceled because of COVID! The show was amazing and left off on, like, five different cliffhangers. Also, we never got to see more of Grizz and Sam. I will always be pissed about it."

bookwhipped

2. The Carrie Diaries (2013-2014)

The CW / Via carriediariesgifs.tumblr.com

"It was so promising. AnnaSophia Robb was a great young Carrie Bradshaw, and I really wanted to see more of the backstory. Plus it was a good amount of cute/funny/dramatic."

katiemoseley5

3. I Am Not Okay With This (2020)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"It was a great show with good diversity in terms of representing queerness/sexuality, and they gave it the axe after one season. It was raw and one of the most relatable teen shows."

ipurdy14

4. Me, Myself, and I (2017-2018)

CBS / Via beepsrichie.tumblr.com

"A recent CBS show with a promising plot of a blended family (a couple who get married and each has a middle school-aged son). The boys have to learn to live together and form a fast friendship. BUT the main plot is told from the perspective of one of the boys over three stages in his life: middle school student, divorced single parent, and elderly business owner. The cast was great, the vibe was so happy, and they captured each time period (including the future!) with wonderful attention to detail. So sad that it only got one season! I was devastated when they canceled it."

ericastevenson323

5. Freaks and Geeks (1999-2000)

NBC / Via giphy.com

"An absolute classic."

sobia88

6. Deadman Wonderland (2011)

tvk, Adult Swim / Via kvnai.tumblr.com

"Such a great horror anime with a really unique plot. I got so invested in it only to realize there was only one season and there was NO CLOSURE! It just, poof, ends."

bmkalmbach

7. Pushing Daises (2007-2009)

ABC / Via spockemon.tumblr.com

"It was such a unique, well-done show. To this day, it's one of my favorites. Unfortunately, it fell victim to the writer strikes and ended prematurely."

magicalyetis

8. Emily Owens, M.D. (2012-2013)

The CW / Via oswaldc.tumblr.com

"I loved how it showed her battling her insecurities while vying for the attention of her crush and competing with her high school rival to impress a doctor at the hospital whose work they've both admired. Mammie Gummer is amazing!"

dougfancy101290

9. Scream Queens (2015-2016)

Fox / Via giphy.com

"We only got two seasons but I thought it was hilarious!"

claire60000

10. The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance (2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"After it won an Emmy, Netflix gave it the boot! It was a fantastic story that used a dying art form (puppetry). It was such a work of art and even though they were close to being done filming a second season, it was still canceled. I am not over this one."

ipurdy14

11. Daybreak (2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"It definitely set up for a second season and had a lot of POC and LGBT+ characters without making it a big deal. It had some high school cliches but also...valid plot points that deal with mental and physical health."

keshawiy

12. Santa Clarita Diet (2017-2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"That show was so funny, serious, and lighthearted. The characters were so good. Plus they ended it on an awful cliffhanger. I wish they did a wrap-up season instead of just canceling it."

annalisek10

13. GLOW (2017-2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"I will forever be salty about Glow being canceled. That show had EVERYTHING. An amazing and diverse cast, body positivity, a banging soundtrack, amazing costumes, and fantastic writing and direction. We deserved at least one more season because there are so many unresolved storylines."

emmanz

14. Project Blue Book (2019-2020)

History Network / Via xihatiancai.tumblr.com

"This was an excellent sci-fi/thriller on History. The plot was fascinating and the cast was great. It received critical acclaim and History said it had their full support, but then it was abruptly canceled after Season 2."

deborahcortlandt

15. Teenage Bounty Hunters (2020)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"It was a solid and enjoyable show that a lot of people identified with. It was never given a chance."

shelbyyarchin

16. Twisted (2013-2014)

ABC Family / Via tumblr.com

"It was so good and just ended on a cliffhanger after one season!! So annoying! We’ll never know who got shot!"

sabrinabecnel08

17. Bunheads (2012-2013)

ABC Family / Via waiting-4-fridays.tumblr.com

"Hands down the best and most underrated show. It had the best writing of any show in recent memory with positive supportive female friendships, honest everyday struggles, and relatable characters that went through ups and downs. None of the characters were perfect, they all had flaws, but that was what made the show so special, you got to see them handle themselves and come to terms with what their lives were. It was smart, witty, and didn't dumb down its jokes! Honestly, I've rewatched it so many times and will choose to again and again because of how amazing it was!"

ccannilla

18. The Get Down (2016-2017)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"It was such a good story filled with BIPOC representation and hip hop/rap history. I hate that it ended up being canceled because they couldn’t get another director."

nicoler4c7a61a25

19. Girl Meets World (2014-2017)

Disney Channel / Via thenitis.tumblr.com

"It was so cute and funny and I loved all the Boy Meets World cameos!"

christinac480a09fe2

20. Anne With an E (2017-2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"Such an amazing and beautiful show raising the incredibly important topics of feminism and racism, and depicting the LGBT+ community in those days. So relevant even right now in our world. Completely heartbroken that it got canceled."

ashriyathampi

21. Sense8 (2015-2018)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"Sense8 should not have been canceled and should have gotten its third season. The cast was diverse and amazing with so much rich storytelling and an interesting concept. Ugh. I'm still upset we only got a pared-down movie instead of a complete final season."

koontzk87

22. Famous in Love (2017-2018)

Freeform / Via giphy.com

"That show had so much potential to be awesome! Plus there were so many loose ends that needed to be tied up."

jades4c1dda494

23. Timeless (2016-2018)

NBC / Via giphy.com

"It was such a fantastic show that shed light on important, but not as well known, historical figures and would often highlight women and POC."

michelleh430be4d5b

24. My So-Called Life (1994-1995)

ABC / Via mysocalledlifeobsession.tumblr.com

"It touched on so many issues like child abuse, drug use, homophobia, and the general awkwardness of being a teenager, but without ever feeling like 'a very special episode' like other sitcoms did in the '90s. It wasn’t like, 'Okay, this week's episode deals with this' — those themes continued throughout the whole series."

audreyt4fe9df5f9

25. Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists (2019)

Freeform / Via giphy.com

"It got left on a cliffhanger and I wanted to see how the whole show turned out. It looked like it would be a bit better than Pretty Little Liars so I was excited and then found out it got canceled."

justanotherfangirl101

26. Terra Nova (2011)

Fox / Via emily-cooper.tumblr.com

"It was on almost a decade ago but I’m still bitter about it. The premise had so much potential, the characters were so interesting, and the first season ended on such a big cliffhanger. It was canceled after one season because it was very expensive to produce but I still miss it."

samiw404c6984a

27. Popular (1999-2001)

The WB / Via roranicuspond.tumblr.com

"It’s a Ryan Murphy show from the ‘90s/‘00s. It was so fucking funny. It got renewed for a third season, they ended on a major cliffhanger, and then the network said 'PSYCH!' and canceled it. I’ll be bitter to my dying day about it. None of his comedies have ever lived up to it."

surfingrockets

28. Higher Ground (2000)

Fox Family / Via haydenchristensengifs.tumblr.com

"It had one season in 2000, but it was amazing. The acting was great, the problems were real, and the people playing teenagers weren't thirty."

halflila

29. The O.A. (2016-2019)

Netflix / Via giphy.com

"I've never seen a show like it. It also ended on an absolute mind-blowing cliffhanger that I can't believe we'll never get to see resolved. But well worth the watch."

christine90125

30. Agent Carter (2015-2016)

ABC / Via sersi.tumblr.com

"I think this was such a strong show in the MCU and Peggy is such an incredible character! Both seasons were strong and I wish we could have seen more. I’m glad they wrapped up Peggy’s (and even Sousa’s!) story later on but still... I would love for them to come back and tell me more about Peggy’s past!"

tabithav4183690a6

31. Spinning Out (2020)

Netflix / Via centernayeon.tumblr.com

"It was such a great show which had a focus on mental health and race. It was a beautiful show that was canceled after one season."

awhitehouse2000

32. Happy Endings (2011-2013)

ABC / Via alexisrose.tumblr.com

"It was an amazing and funny show. Ten times better than Friends! I was so sad when it was canceled. I remember when they teased a comeback a few years ago and was so sad when nothing came of it. Still a fan of all the actors!

nursebrown915

33. And finally, Don't Trust the B---- in Apartment 23 (2012-2013)

ABC / Via giphy.com

"It was a fun, crass show about how friendships can change people's lives for the better. Plus it had Krysten Ritter, Eric Andre, Dreama Walker, and James Van Der Beek as James Van Der Beek. I think it was just with the wrong network at the wrong time, otherwise, we'd be on Season 11 by now!"

glassmeridith

Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.

TV and Movies

Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

Newsletter signup form