Skip To Content

    People Shared The TV And Movie Characters Who They Undoubtedly Believe Should've Been The Main Character, And Several Points Were Made

    So glad we can all agree that Bonnie carried The Vampire Diaries.

    We recently asked the BuzzFeed Community which secondary character from a TV show or movie would've made a better main character than the actual main character, and boy did they have lots to say! Here are some of the best responses:

    1. Bonnie Bennett from The Vampire Diaries

    Annette Brown /The CW / Courtesy: Everett Collection

    "You can’t have her save the day every time and then relegate her to secondary status. Plus, she was much more interesting and exciting than Elena."


    2. Maeve Wiley from Sex Education

    Sam Taylor / Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection

    "Otis is a good protagonist, but Maeve has such depth in her character and is such a pleasure to watch in every scene she's in."


    3. Eloise Bridgerton from Bridgerton

    Liam Daniel / Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection

    "I would FAR rather see Eloise's struggle to independence than I would Daphne's woes."


    4. Sandra from Superstore

    Nbc / NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

    "I want to know what her life is like, especially with her hyper memory."


    5. Gustavo Fring from Breaking Bad

    Ursula Coyote / AMC / courtesy Everett Collection

    "Walter White irritated and bored me! Gus is a much more interesting character, and the story would have been so much better!"


    6. Jemma Simmons from Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

    Mitchell Haaseth / ABC / courtesy Everett Collection

    "Simmons rather than Daisy. She was the brains behind everything and made more mistakes than Daisy. She had a different way of thinking, and her badass-ness is more hidden, which I think is really cool."


    7. Storm from the X-Men franchise

    20th Century Fox Film Corp. All rights reserved. / Courtesy Everett Collection

    "Listen. I love Wolverine. I really do. But did almost every movie HAVE to be about him? Give me a Storm movie! A Magneto origin! A little something different, people!"


    8. Nick Miller from New Girl

    20thcentfox /20thCentFox/Courtesy Everett Collection

    "Hands down!!! It should have been called the Nick Miller Show."


    9. Any of the Weasleys from the Harry Potter franchise

    Warner Bros. Pictures

    "Maybe not Percy 😂 , but I would literally take a movie about the Weasleys and give back all the Harry stuff if I could. Harry is a good character; I just don’t think he needed so many movies about him."


    10. Taystee from Orange Is the New Black

    JoJo Whilden / Netflix / courtesy Everett Collection

    “I know toward the end of the show, she did become more of the main focus and she got more flashbacks and stuff, but they really could’ve centered it around her more. Or literally anyone but Piper. In my opinion, Piper had no depth and was a boring main character. Taystee ended up changing the most from who she was at the beginning of the show and was just an amazing character to watch grow over the years."


    11. Raven Reyes from The 100

    Sergei Bachlakov / The CW Network / courtesy Everett Collection

    "She saves humanity like four times and rarely gets credit for it. Plus, she's Latina and disabled, two things that aren't very common in television leads. She's the smartest character on the show and is also sassy, assertive, and a little cocky. She's just a lot more interesting than Clarke and ends up having a much more positive impact on the ending too."


    12. Primrose Everdeen from The Hunger Games franchise

    Murray Close/Lionsgate/Courtesy Everett Collection

    "It would be great to read from Prim’s point of view since she spends so little time with Katniss in the series!"


    13. Karen and Jack from Will & Grace


    "I know I'm not the only one who thinks Karen & Jack would have made a way better show than Will & Grace."


    14. Dean Craig Pelton and Ben Chang from Community

    Yahoo /Yahoo/Courtesy Everett Collection

    "I want to watch a Community spinoff starring them. It's already a weird school, but focused more on them, it’d be even weirder. More costumes, Dalmatians, amnesia, mannequin parts, and most importantly, more greasing up an almost naked Chang so he can climb in the air vents!" 


    15. Janet from The Good Place

    Nbc / NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

    "I would love a version of The Good Place all about Janet. Eleanor was a strong choice for the main character, but Janet had such a unique and compelling position within the show’s realm. Plus, she was hilarious!"  


    16. Hermione Granger from the Harry Potter franchise

    Jaap Buitendijk/ Warner Bros /Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection

    "She was the smartest one in the group, and she literally got them out of trouble most of the time. I like Harry and all, but still."


    17. Fat Amy from the Pitch Perfect trilogy

    Richard Cartwright/Universal Pictures/Courtesy Everett Collection

    "Definitely fat Amy!"


    18. Mercedes Jones from Glee

    Adam Rose / Fox / Courtesy: Everett Collection

    "She would've made a much more inspiring and likable main character than Rachel Berry, IMO."


    19. Lane Kim from Gilmore Girls

    Marsha Blackburn /The CW /Courtesy Everett Collection

    "As much as I love Lorelei, I find Rory boring, entitled, and self-centered. Lane has a much more interesting story — strict, ultra-religious parents whose rules she has to creatively sneak around, all while still trying to please them. Also, IMO, her personality is so much better than Rory's, and I actually cared about what happened to her. A close second would have to be Paris Geller." 


    20. Shane Walsh from The Walking Dead


    "He should've been the main lead. As much as I liked Rick as a leader, it would have been an interesting twist to see Shane be a leader. I would have also liked to see the relationship dynamic between Shane, Carl, and the rest of the characters."


    21. Ella Lopez from Lucifer

    Fox / courtesy Everett Collection

    "She grew up in a rough neighborhood in Detroit and had a criminal background. Her 'guardian angel' was literally the angel of death who took a liking to her. Even though she had a rough childhood and a reputation, she still became a forensic scientist. Some things we've learned about her is that her grandmother taught her how to pick locks, she's been banned from one casino at least in Vegas, and dated a serial killer."


    22. Barney Stinson from How I Met Your Mother

    Ron P. Jaffe / CBS / Courtesy Everett Collection

    "His stuff was much more interesting than Ted's, who I just happen to dislike."


    23. Han Solo from Star Wars: Episode IV — A New Hope

    20th Century Fox Film Corp. / courtesy Everett Collection

    "It would have been cool if he was the main character instead of Luke. It could have told the story of him kind of getting sucked into this adventure and learning about this 'force' that he doesn't really believe in. We'd be experiencing Luke's path through the eyes of someone who is learning as we do."


    24. Rosalie Hale from The Twilight Saga

    Summit Entertainment

    "Honestly, Rosalie in Twilight. Her short backstory in The Twilight Saga: Eclipse was far more interesting than anything that happened with Bella and Edward."


    25. Luna Lovegood from the Harry Potter franchise

    Warner Bros / Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection

    "Her life seems so interesting, even before she met Harry. I want to see her growing up with her father, learning about Nargles and whatnot. Luna is brilliant, but she only got to use her wits once or twice in the series. I want to see what she can really do, and if she were the main character, we could really dive in on her smarts. Not to mention we would get to see a lot more of Ravenclaw besides just Cho."


    26. Jasper Hale from the Twilight franchise

    Summit Entertainment

    "He has a whole amazing backstory and is one of the deepest characters. He could have a whole set of movies on his own."


    27. Derek Hale from Teen Wolf


    "He has one of the most tragic backstories ever! It would have been so interesting to see him try to overcome his past/move past his guilt and build a healthy pack. And I wouldn't say no to something developing with Stiles (even if it ended up being just a really strong friendship)." 


    28. Cece Parekh from New Girl

    Jesse Giddings / Fox / Courtesy: Everett Collection

    “She was cast aside as the ‘pretty best friend’ during the first few seasons, but later on, her life was brought more into the spotlight, and those are some of my favorite moments. I would definitely enjoy a spinoff with her as the main character.”


    29. Titus Andromedon or Lillian Kaushtupper from Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

    Eric Liebowitz /Netflix / courtesy Everett Collection

    "I do love Kimmy, but I'd watch the hell out of an Unbreakable Titus Andromedon & Lillian Kaushtupper. I mean, Titus Andromedon is one of the best characters of all time; his quotes are legendary. And Carol Kane, 'nuff said."


    30. Andre Harris from Victorious


    "Or heck, even Trina." 


    31. And last but never least, Santana Lopez from Glee

    Mike Yarish / Fox / Courtesy: Everett Collection

    "MUCH more interesting and just as talented."


    Are there any characters who you believe deserved to be the lead character more than the actual lead? Let us know in the comments below.

    Note: Submissions have been edited for both length and/or clarity.

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form