Music

Did Meghan Trainor Plagiarize A K-Pop Artist To Make Her Hit Song "All About That Bass"?

The creator of the original song seems to think so.

Posted on

Meghan Trainor's "All About That Bass" is currently sitting at number 2 on the Billboard Hot 100.

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com

Koyote released their song, "Happy Mode," in 2006. Here are both songs right after each other.

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com

And here are both songs at the same time.

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com

Earlier this week, the songwriter tweeted: "I am consulting a specialized lawyer." In the tweet, he linked to a Naver article about the controversy.

전문 변호사와 상담하고 있습니다. http://t.co/VbuX1fIWMH

주영훈@climix_joo

전문 변호사와 상담하고 있습니다. http://t.co/VbuX1fIWMH

9:57 PM - 25 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

Interestingly though, Joo Young Hoon and Meghan Trainor both might have taken inspiration from Phish. The band released a song in 1989 that is also pretty similar.

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com

Nothing is new under the sun, after all. In music especially, phrases and melodies are notoriously difficult to trace.

BuzzFeed has reached out to a representative for Meghan Trainor for comment.

If it is a matter of plagiarism, Trainor's label could be on the hook. Last week, a New York federal judge ruled that Sony was liable for a song Shakira was accused of plagiarizing. In that case, though, concepts and lyrics, in addition to melody, were also borrowed.

In the case of Meghan Trainor and Koyote, the songs have significantly different lyrics. "All About That Bass" is about flaunting a not-thin frame, while "Happy Mode" is about staying positive through rough times. Here's a loose translation of the latter's chorus: "Even though love left, don't be sad and cry / New love will find it's way / Sadness is only resting before it leaves."