This Italian TikToker Went Viral For “Gently Correcting” Emily Mariko’s Lemon Pasta Recipe, And After Trying It Myself, I’m Gonna Make It Weekly

    If you thought the baked feta pasta was good, mentally prepare yourself for this one.

    If you've ever so much as scrolled through TikTok, even just once, you know Emily Mariko. The food and lifestyle influencer is always cooking up something delicious-looking in her immaculate, shiny kitchen, whether it's her mega-viral salmon bowls or a freshly baked dish of homemade mac 'n' cheese. One of her latest dishes to go viral was her version of spaghetti al limone, a popular pasta dish made with zingy lemons and lots of cheese. And naturally, people had a bone to pick with her. Or several.

    Emily eating pasta with a glass of red wine on the table

    Some criticized her for allegedly "copying" the recipe of chef Frank Prisinzano, owner of Lil' Frankie's in New York City, without credit. (Even the Duolingo owl had something to say.)

    Duolingo owl asking Emily or Frankie

    Others found the idea of lemons in pasta downright revolting. To each their own, I guess.

    Comment: Get that lemon...OFF THAT PASTA!

    But as I sifted through the comments of TikTokers caring way too much about a 29-year-old home cook making a simple dinner in her own kitchen, I saw a lot of comments like these — and of course, I had to investigate.

    Comments including "ngl the Italian German lady did it better" and "POV: you just came from the Italian lady's video"

    It only took a few clicks before I found myself watching a Stitch of Emily's spaghetti al limone video uploaded by @mammaculinaria, who goes by "Claudia." In her video, she addresses Emily directly with a bubbly "Hey, girl," then prefaces the rest of the video with "Please don't take this personally, and there's no hate at all in this video."

    Woman saying that the squeezed lemon put inside the pasta doesn't really make sense

    She goes on to say that after watching Emily's "lemon pasta" video, she wanted to "show her a better version," in hopes that she'd somehow see the video and try it herself. There's not an ounce of condescension in her voice, either — just one passionate home cook sharing a beloved recipe with another.

    Woman saying "You probably won't even see this Stitch, but who knows; I would be glad if you tried this version of lemon pasta!"

    At the time this post was published, Claudia's video had garnered close to 20 million views. While I don't believe Emily has tried it for herself yet, I can confirm that hundreds of thousands of other TikTokers have. So naturally, I knew I had to reach out to Claudia directly to get to the bottom of what makes this recipe so wildly delicious, and then try it in my own kitchen.

    "My followers knew my lemon pasta long before it was a trend on TikTok," Claudia told BuzzFeed, "and a lot of them tagged me in Emily's video asking me if I would show her how to make it. I didn't want to seem like that typical Italian who wants to judge how pasta is made, so I tried my best to let her know I come in peace." (From my POV, it worked.)

    Images of Claudia cooking with the caption "she first posted about her recipe over two years ago"

    Her lemon pasta recipe was actually born in Positano, on the Amalfi Coast of Italy, where, as she describes it, "the lemons are like sweet gold." The recipe has evolved, through trial and error, to the point where she makes it at least once a week for her family.

    Scenic view of Positano, Italy

    To make Claudia's viral lemon pasta, the ingredients couldn't be simpler. Some people might even say they're shockingly simple! (I'm "some people," for the record.)

    A cutting board with ingredients: butter, fresh basil, garlic, crushed red pepper, lemons, and pasta

    STEP 1: This step just so happens to be the most important one — zest and juice your lemons.

    Claudia grating lemon in her TikTok

    Then juice 'em! You'll ultimately want about ¼ cup of lemon juice when you're done, so depending on how juicy your lemons are, you might need only two of the three.

    Visual of lemon being juiced on countertop

    STEP 2: Bring a medium pot of heavily salted water to a rolling boil.

    STEP 3: In a large skillet, combine your sliced garlic, crushed red pepper, butter (or, as Claudia calls it, "love"), and just enough olive oil to coat the bottom of the skillet.

    Ingredients being added to the pan

    It should look a little something like this:

    STEP 4: Add your pasta to the oil mixture along with two ladlefuls of your salted pasta water, and continuously shake the skillet to combine everything.

    Pasta in the pan with other ingredients

    The rocking of the skillet back and forth on your stove, as Claudia demonstrates in her video, helps the pasta to combine with the starchy pasta water. However, if your pasta needs a little more coaxing to soak up all that saucy goodness, feel free to toss gently with tongs.

    Your pasta is done cooking when it looks something like this: Each strand of angel hair will be tender (but not flimsy!), and the sauce will look glossy and starchy as it bubbles.

    Pasta in pan with captions with arrows to "starchy bubbles" and "tender pasta"

    STEP 5: Off the heat, toss in your whole basil leaves, reserved lemon zest, and lemon juice.

    Lemon zest and basil leaves added to pasta in pan

    That's it! Easy, right?

    Pan of completed lemon pasta dish

    To serve Claudia's lemon pasta, twirl the angel hair with your tongs and nestle each serving onto a plate. Alternatively, you can literally just pile pasta onto plates without worrying about presentation. You're just gonna eat it, anyway.

    Arrows pointing to lemon in dish

    THE VERDICT: For a dish that only requires 15 minutes of work, I was absolutely blown away. Hell, even if it took an hour to make, I'd be equally impressed.

    Surprisingly, you're not hit over the head with that lemony flavor, either. It's certainly a major component, sure, but it doesn't overpower any of the other flavors.

    The writer with a bowl of the angel hair pasta, with caption "TBH, it's the perfect amount of lemon" and arrow pointing to the pasta

    Maybe Emily Mariko hasn't gotten around to trying this one yet, but in her defense, she's a busy lady. I'm sure she'll come around to it. For now, I'm officially adding my voice to the chorus of @mammaculinaria die-hards who just really, reallyyy want Miss Mariko to taste it for herself.

    Ross Yoder's comment: Emily this looks UNBELIEVABLE — and also, you should absolutely try @mammaculinaria's different (but similar!) lemon pasta recipe; you would love"

    If you try out this recipe in your own home, let me know what you think in the comments.

    To keep up with Claudia and her deliciously simple, home cook–friendly recipes, you can follow along via her German TikTok account or her English one, or check her out on Instagram and YouTube.