• Quiz badge

13 Of The Most Genuinely Baffling, Altogether Confusing, And Low-Key Unidentifiable Cookie Cutters That Have Ever Graced This Earth

I'm legitimately stumped — and you will be too.

Recently, a coworker introduced me to the endlessly entertaining subreddit r/whatismycookiecutter. TBH, it was the moment my life changed for the better. So I rounded up the most bizarre, inexplicable, and genuinely dumbfounding "mystery" cookie cutters I could find.

(Be sure to record your guesses via the polls as you move through this post...because, like, I genuinely need the help.)

1. Here's this...thing...doing something. Or nothing at all! Your call.

Cookie cutter that's difficult to identify — maybe a person bent over

2. Any thoughts?

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify, with a lump in the middle and two misshapen lumps at the bottom

3. I get what they were going for here, but...actually, no, I don't.

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify, but maybe showing a face on one side

4. Y'all, I'm stumped.

Cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be side view of a pregnant person

5. Any bright ideas as to what this could be?

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be a cartoon character running or on fire

6. WAIT, wait. I've got it.

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be a misshapen animal

7. ...

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be an embryo or a lumpy peanut

8. I actually feel really confident about this one, but let's see what you think.

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be an electric can opener

9. I have a feeling I know what this is, but my lips are sealed.

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be two beer bottles next to each other

10. ...what?

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be an amoeba

11. (Royally stumped again!)

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be a Pez dispenser

12. Hit me with your best guess.

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but could be a cartoon character with a tail running

13. And finally: bunny or bear?

A cookie cutter that's difficult to identify but looks like a bunny one way and a teddy bear upside down