Poll Quiz·Posted on Feb 21, 2023Would You Rather Date Or Dump These Characters Made Famous By Penn Badgley?Let's see which version of Penn you love the most.by Michele BirdBuzzFeed ContributorLinkFacebookPinterestTwitterMailBuzzFeed Quiz Party! Take this quiz with friends in real time and compare resultsCheck it out! Penn Badgley is having a moment with the recent release of You Season 4. If you've been a fan of the actor since his early days in Hollywood, I'm curious which of his characters you'd rather date or dump. Cast your vote now: