Skip To Content

    In Another Life, These 21 Celebrities Would've Been Cast In The "Twilight" Movies

    I'd still be Team Edward regardless.

    1. Jennifer Lawrence auditioned to play Bella, but at the time "it was just another audition" and she had no idea the franchise was going to become as big as it is.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    2. Eclipse screenwriter Melissa Rosenberg originally pictured Channing Tatum for the role of Riley Byers — she thought he would play the role "beautifully" — but at the time, he was already working on several other movies.

    Getty Images / Summit

    3. Dave Franco screen-tested for the role of Edward Cullen and even read in front of Twilight director Catherine Hardwick.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    4. Vanessa Hudgens was rumored to have auditioned for the role of Leah Clearwater, and while nothing came of it, Ashley Greene said she thought Vanessa "would be great" in the role.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    5. Twilight author Stephenie Meyer had her own casting in mind for Edward Cullen, and her first choice was Henry Cavill. However, at the time of auditions, he was 24 and too old for the role.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    6. Michelle Trachtenberg — who has known Catherine Hardwick since the movie Thirteen — was actually in the running to play Bella and joked, "There was definitely interest here and there because there's only so few pale girls in Hollywood."

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    7. Dustin Milligan — who's worked with Kristen Stewart twice already — auditioned for the role of Edward and joked he didn't get it because he didn't have a British accent.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    8. Stephenie Meyer really wanted Charlie Hunnam to play Carlisle Cullen after she'd seen him in Nicholas Nickleby, where he "pretty much was Carlisle in that movie."

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    9. Lucy Hale was a huge fan of the books and auditioned for the Twilight franchise twice: once to play Alice Cullen and another time to play Jane.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection / Summit

    10. Several Twilight fans rallied so hard for Tom Felton to play Riley Byers that when he was asked about the rumors, he said, "I'll be ready when they want me!"

    Getty Images / Summit

    11. Scott Eastwood auditioned to play Edward Cullen, but remembered he just went "through the motions" and didn't "try all that hard" because he didn't really want to be in a YA movie.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    12. John Stamos was Stephenie Meyer's choice to play Laurent, and she was really hoping he'd sign on to do a cameo.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    13. Stephenie Meyer's first choice for Bella was actually Emily Browning, but when she was offered the role, she turned it down.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    14. Steven Strait was another one of Stephenie Meyer's original casting choices for Jacob Black, but also was too old when auditions rolled around.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    15. Instead, Stephenie Meyer pictured Tyler Posey playing Jacob. He ended up reading for the part but found out he didn't get it months later after a conversation with Taylor Lautner at another audition.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    16. Studio execs wanted to recast Jacob for New Moon because they felt Taylor Lautner wasn't big enough for the role, and they prematurely stated Michael Copon would play "the new Jacob."

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    17. One of Lily Collins' first auditions as a young actor was for the role of Bella Swan.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    18. Stephenie Meyer's first choice to play Charlie Swan was actually John C. Reilly. She felt he was "so perfect," even though it'd be a reach to get him to sign on.

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    19. Stephenie Meyer also felt like Vince Vaughn could play Charlie, as long as he added a "few extra pounds and a receding hairline."

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    20. Shiloh Fernandez auditioned for Edward but shared that he was "nervous and awkward" and that he and Kristen Stewart "didn't mesh."

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    21. Finally, Breaking Dawn director Bill Condon wanted to cast James Franco in the movie, but he changed his mind because he felt James was so famous that it would "feel like 'Where's Waldo?'"

    Getty Images / Everett Collection

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form