back to top

25 Questions All "One Tree Hill" Fans Need Answered

How did we last nine seasons???

Posted on

1. Why did Peyton live alone as a 16-year-old?

The CW

2. And when her dad WAS around, why was he OK with her live-streaming her bedroom every day?

Where are those parental controls?
Via punkndisorderly.com

Where are those parental controls?

3. Speaking of Peyton's parents, what's going on with that family tree??? Why was she living with two people who turned out to not be her parents?

The CW

4. And why did she have three dads???

CW
CW
CW

5. Did Lucas and Nathan not know each other existed until high school or what?... Because like, small town.

The CW / Via Netflix

6. Why did Haley's parents allow her to get married when she was 16?

The CW / Via Netflix

7. Also, why are famous musicians coming through town all the time?

The CW / Via Netflix

8. Why did Dan only get like five years prison time for LITERALLY MURDERING HIS BROTHER?

The CW / Via Netflix

9. WHERE DID PEYTON AND LUCAS EVEN GO???

The CW / Via youtube.com

10. And is having a baby seat in a convertible like this even safe????

The CW / Via youtube.com

11. Why did Lucas come back to the show rocking a middle part and act like it was OK?

Michael Tackett / The CW

12. How did approximately 29 people get hit by cars throughout the series and not one of them died?

The CW / Via Netflix

13. Why did Pete from Fall Out Boy have so much spare time that he was able to listen to Peyton's podcast?

The CW / Via fanpop.com

14. Why did no one care that Rachel literally became a new person with the help of plastic surgery...while in high school???

The CW / Via Netflix

15. When exactly does Haley have time to study and achieve good grades while she's running around being a musician?

The CW / Via Netflix

16. Why did Lucas know so much about birds?

17. Basically, why is Tree Hill the most unsafe town EVER? And why would anyone want to live there?

Crazy nannies, murderous brothers, kidnappers, stalkers...
The CW / Via Netflix

Crazy nannies, murderous brothers, kidnappers, stalkers...

18. WHY WAS THE MOST CLUMSY PERSON RESPONSIBLE FOR CARRYING DAN'S HEART?

Also, would a trained therapy dog really go for Dan's heart?
The CW / Via Netflix

Also, would a trained therapy dog really go for Dan's heart?

19. Why was Kevin Federline on the show?

Fred Norris / The CW

20. Why the hell was fake Derek (Ian) not in jail?

The CW / Via Netflix

21. Why was Stephen from Laguna Beach on the show and where was LC???

The CW / Via Netflix

22. Why was Haley so excited to get a plastic bracelet covered in Cracker Jack crumbs?

The CW / Via Netflix

23. Why did NO ONE do anything about Peyton driving through red lights?

The CW / Via Netflix

24. Why was there only one apartment in town for everyone to live in?

Nathan, Brooke, Haley...
The CW / Via Netflix

Nathan, Brooke, Haley...

25. And, quite frankly, how did everyone achieve fame and fortune by the age of 23?

Seriously, tell us your secret.
The CW / Via coolspotters.com

Seriously, tell us your secret.

The best things at three price points