Aubrey Plaza And 20 Other Celebs Who Should Guest Star On Season 2 Of “Poker Face”

Let's make it happen, Poker Face casting department!

If you didn't hear, Poker Face is officially getting a second season.

NBC / Via giphy.com

Considering how jam-packed with guest stars Season 1 is, I can't help but wonder about who might pop up in Season 2 alongside Natasha Lyonne.

NBC / Via giphy.com

Here are 23 celebrities I think would make great additions to the cast — let's see if you agree!

1. John Boyega

Lia Toby / Getty Images

Most of John Boyega's TV work has been voice-only, which is a travesty.

2. Steve Buscemi

Maria Moratti / Getty Images

A show like Poker Face is honestly begging for Steve Buscemi's brand of weird.

3. Jennifer Coolidge

Michael Tran / AFP via Getty Images

There are a million things Poker Face could do with Jennifer Coolidge and I'd be happy to see any of them.

4. Alan Cumming

Valerie Macon / AFP via Getty Images

Who wouldn't want to see Alan Cumming trading barbs with Natasha Lyonne?

5. Matthew Gray Gubler

Gary Gershoff / Getty Images

We need an episode with "Orpheus Syndrome" vibes in Season 2 solely so Matthew Gray Gubler can star in it.

6. Allison Janney

Rodin Eckenroth / Getty Images

You can't go wrong casting Allison Janney — she could play any number of roles (including maybe Charlie's mom?).

7. Lucy Liu

Michael Kovac / Getty Images for IMDb

Lucy Liu should be on every TV show until the end of time. Next.

8. Melanie Lynskey

Dia Dipasupil / WireImage via Getty Images

Same goes for Melanie Lynskey!

9. Tatiana Maslany

Mathew Tsang / Getty Images

Anyone who's seen Orphan Black knows Tatiana Maslany is particularly chameleon-like, even for an actor, so there's no limit to what she could do on Poker Face. (I myself would love to see her as a villain again.)

10. Indya Moore

Pascal Le Segretain / Getty Images for amfAR

PLEASE let Indya Moore play a murderous supermodel.

11. Bob Odenkirk

Axelle / FilmMagic via Getty Images

Bob Odenkirk's a little on the young side for it but with that voice, I'd love for him to play Charlie's dad.

12. Elliot Page

Michael Tran / AFP via Getty Images

Elliot Page has talked about how much he loves But I'm a Cheerleader, so I bet he'd jump at the chance to work with Natasha Lyonne.

13. Keke Palmer

Taylor Hill / WireImage via Getty Images

I'm extremely confident the banter between Keke Palmer and Natasha Lyonne would be top-tier.

14. Randall Park

Mark Von Holden / Variety via Getty Images

Randall Park is basically TV royalty at this point, and I'd love to see him play a murderer.

15. Pedro Pascal

Axelle / FilmMagic via Getty Images

At this point, are there any shows Pedro Pascal wouldn't be welcome on?

16. Victoria Pedretti

Dominique Charriau / WireImage via Getty Images

Season 4 of You has made me acutely aware of the Victoria Pedretti-shaped hole in my life, and her appearance on even just one episode of Poker Face would definitely help.

17. Kal Penn

Michael Tran / AFP via Getty Images

Kal Penn is always a welcome sight and would play a great straight man against Charlie.

18. Aubrey Plaza

Amy Sussman / WireImage via Getty Images

Aubrey Plaza and Natasha Lyonne played love interests once, and I need them to do it again, if only for it to end in despair.

19. Jasmin Savoy Brown

Mark Von Holden / Variety via Getty Images

I'll really just take any excuse to see more of Jasmin Savoy Brown in pretty much everything.

20. Octavia Spencer

Frederic J. Brown / AFP via Getty Images

I mean, it's Octavia Spencer. I feel, like, enough said?

21. And finally, Maya Rudolph

Axelle / FilmMagic via Getty Images

Considering Maya Rudolph is an executive producer on the show, it just feels like a wasted opportunity not to have her on it.

Who else would you want to see on Poker Face? Sound off in the comments!