1. Ryan Phillippe as Billy Douglas on One Life to Live
Brokeback Mountain was a tour de force, but that’s nothing compared to Ryan’s portrayal of Billy, the first gay teenager ever to be portrayed on a daytime soap opera. That lasted from 1992-1993, pre-Reese, and butt scene in Cruel Intentions.
2. Meg Ryan on As The World Turns as Betsy Stewart Andropoulos
Meg’s rom-com career would be nothing if not for her soap stint from 1982 to 1984, as Betsy—a trust fund baby in Oakdale. There were multiple marriages, a pregnancy, car accident, and countless other soapy dramas. That’s all part of the biz, folks.
3. Kevin Bacon on Guiding Light as T.J. Werner
Pre-Footloose in 1984, there was Kevin Bacon as an alcoholic teen on Guiding Light.
4. Parker Posey as Tess Shelby on As The World Turns
Parker played the role of Tess, a devious teenager, from 1991-1992. I can only assume she pulled from real-life experience.
6. David Hasselhoff on The Young and the Restless as Dr. Snapper Foster
You may know The Hoff best from his starring roles on Baywatch and that video where he eats a burger. But between 1975 and 1982, The Hoff played Dr. Snapper Foster, who got through med school thanks to the financial support of his manicurist sister.
7. Marisa Tomei as Marcy Thompson on As the World Turns
Marisa Tomei is sexy as hell, but from 1983 to 1985, she accused a man of sexual harassment, and then went on to marry a legit prince: Lord Stewart Cushing. Her character, Marcy, then became Lady Marcy Cushing. It’s brilliant.
8. Leonardo DiCaprio as Mason Capwell on Santa Barbara
Even at 16, Leo still had epic hair! In 1990 he played a young Mason Capwell. He was wealthy, troubled, and loved button-down shirts. For some reason, there’s not very much footage floating around from this series. Maybe it all sank with the Titanic? (Corny joke, wah wah.)
10. Julianne Moore on As the World Turns as Frannie Hughes Crawford
In 1986, one of Julianne’s big breaks came in the form of playing a young Frannie. I’m not sure what’s better: her amazing cheekbones or those ’80s bangs.
Let’s see Julianne once more, shall we?
11. Rick Springfield as Dr. Noah Drake on General Hospital
Continuing on in the grand tradition of troubled doctors, the “Jessie’s Girl” singer played a heartbreaker of a doctor from 1981 to 1983 in Port Charles.
12. Ray Liotta as Joey Perrini on Another World
Before he played rough and tough gangsters, he was the lovestruck hero on Another Life from 1978 to 1981.
15. Jonathan Jackson and Amber Tamblyn on General Hospital
My 13-year-old self would have swooned to be in Amber’s shoes in 1995. Just saying!
18. Sarah Michelle Gellar as Kendall Hart Lang on All My Children
From 1993 to 1995, Sarah Michelle Gellar played the evil daughter of Erica Kane. Based off of some of Sarah’s later roles, this isn’t too much of a stretch. (Looking at you, Kathryn in Cruel Intentions.)
Oh, and did I mention that this character is technically the product of a rape that occurred on Erica’s 14th birthday? Yeah, dramz!
19. Josh Duhamel and Elizabeth Banks on All My Children
Josh Duhamel played Leo duPres, and Banks was a legit waitress he seduces. It’s a tough job, but these two got to do it!
On a related note: I wouldn’t complain if they reprised these roles.