Skip To Content

    30 Non-Diamond Engagement Rings They're Sure To Say "I Do" To

    Find something your beau will dig! From amethysts to emeralds to moonstones to (gasp!) cubic zirconia!

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI β€” prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. A gorgeous cluster that'll be a winner for anyone whose favorite color is purple.

    Louisa Gallery / Etsy

    BTW, I think purple is my new favorite color now.

    Get it from Louisa Gallery on Etsy for $799 (available in quarter sizes 5–9).

    2. A leafy set more or less made for the person who's already sent you a million Pinterest boards about fall weddings.


    Hint, hint.

    Get it from Amazon for $155.99 (available in half sizes 5–9).

    3. A topaz and gold creation you can pair with all sorts of pretty gems when it comes time to pick out a wedding band.

    Oore / Etsy

    Get it from Oore on Etsy for $795 (available in three gold types and quarter sizes 3–9.5).

    4. A rainbow moonstone solitaire with an organic but polished look full of details that won't be *too* flashy.


    Get it from Catbird for $945 (available in half sizes 4–7).

    5. A hammered band you can customize with several widths for a perfect fit for your perfect person.

    Get Noticed Jewelry / Etsy

    Get it from Get Noticed Jewelry on Etsy for $12+ (available in bright silver or oxidized, seven widths, and sizes 2–15).

    6. A refined option with a stone that'll look nearly as blue and gorgeous as their eyes.


    Get it from Amazon for $49.99 (available in whole sizes 5-9).

    7. An art deco looker people may just stop them to ask about on the street.


    Get it from Amazon for $19.90+ (available in eight color combos and whole sizes 5–10).

    8. A meteorite ring for a look that'll be outta this world.

    Jewelry By Johan / Etsy


    Get it from Jewelry By Johan on Etsy for $1,575 (available in quarter sizes 4–16).

    9. A bright cocktail ring you can get in their favorite color because this is about you guys and no one else!

    Blue Nile

    Get it from Blue Nile for $450 (available in nine gemstones and half sizes 4.5–8.5).

    10. A delicate aquamarine dream they'll be so impressed you snagged on Etsy!

    Dawn Vertrees Jewelry / Etsy

    Get it from Dawn Vertrees Jewelry on Etsy for $925 (available in quarter sizes 4.5–12).

    11. A minimalist band with some low-key ornamentation, in case your boo could care less about any stone.


    Get it from Amazon for $9.99 (available in half sizes 5–10).

    12. A blue topaz number set in sterling silver for a surprisingly affordable option that'll dazzle.


    Get it from Walmart for $31.99 (available in sizes 5–9).

    Also check out the same ring with a lab-created opal or ruby.

    13. A prismatic band to satisfy those whose multi-faceted jewelry taste doesn't include gems.


    Get it from Amazon for $10.99 (available in whole sizes 4–9).

    14. A pink morganite oval cut for an elegant, pretty option.

    Aquamarise / Etsy

    Get it from Aquamarise on Etsy for $49.99 (available in whole sizes 5–8).

    15. A pearl ring as a stone alternative that'll always look like a classic.


    Get it from Nordstrom for $450 (available in sizes 6–8).

    16. A raw stone option to prove you don't need the shine factor to stun. / Via

    Get it from Raw By Olivia Mar on Etsy for $199+ (available in four finishes and half sizes 4–12).

    17. A morganite solitaire with a rose gold infinity band you won't help but congratulate yourself over and over again for picking.


    Get it from Amazon for $158+ (available in two carat weights and half sizes 4–8.5).

    18. An aqua wonder ready to make them forget about all the other colors.

    Madelynn Cassin Designs / Etsy

    Get it from Madelynn Cassin Designs on Etsy for $1,602 (available in three finishes and quarter sizes 3–10).

    19. A goth-leaning number as something that'll look anything but ordinary.


    Get it from Amazon for $9.99+ (available in seven color combos and half sizes 4–12.5).

    20. A green sapphire available in a variety of tones and gold options as be a custom choice within reach.

    Envero Jewelry / Etsy

    Get it from Envero Jewelry on Etsy for $330+ (available in nine kinds of gemstones and three types of gold).

    21. A white sapphire look for the person who has your heart forever and ever.


    FYI, this sapphire was created in a lab.

    Get it from Walmart for $41.99 (available in sizes 4–10).

    Also check out a similar heart-shaped ring from Walmart with a created blue sapphire.

    22. A customizable ring you know will be unlike anything else out there.


    Get it from Amazon for $74.95 (available in half sizes 5–12).

    23. A crystal-encrusted love bird with a triple threat secret your bae can show off to everyone within view.

    Alexis Bittar

    Get them from Alexis Bittar for $155 (available in sizes 6–8).

    24. An amethyst ensnared in branches for a fairytale twist on a solitaire setting.

    G & S / Etsy

    Get it from G & S on Etsy for $413.99 (available in half sizes 3–14).

    25. A rose gold eternity band set with cubic zirconia that'll serve as a budget-friendly take on a gorgeous style.


    Get it from Jet for $41.35 (available in sizes 5–10).

    26. A vibrant emerald stacker everyone may just slobber over, so maybe have a bib at the ready when you propose?


    Get it from Catbird for $905 (available in half sizes 4–8).

    27. A smoky quartz vintage style everyone will assume is a family heirloom β€” maybe it'll become one!

    Louisa Gallery / Etsy

    Get it from Louisa Gallery on Etsy for $215 (available in quarter sizes 3–16).

    28. A cubic zirconia beaut to satisfy someone who doesn't want you to spend the coin on a diamond but still digs the look.


    Get it from Walmart for $99.99 (available in sizes 5–9).

    29. An unexpected modern mix of a white sapphire, hammered band, and rose gold to make for a unique choice that'll stand the test of time.

    Node Form Weddings / Etsy

    Get it from Node Form Weddings on Etsy for $840+ (available in five sapphire weights and quarter sizes 4–9).

    30. A moonstone dazzler with a smattering of diamonds (we won't tell!) to draw attention to the main attraction.

    NyFineJewelry / Etsy

    Get it from NyFineJewelry on Etsy for $555+ (available in six types of gold and quarter sizes 3–9.5).

    Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.

    Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!

    Allison Krausman / BuzzFeed

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form