Skip To Content

    I'm In The Middle Of Rewatching "Criminal Minds" And IDK How I Missed All These Famous People

    From April Ludgate to deranged serial killer. Whodda thought?

    1. Aubrey Plaza as Cat Adams

    Christopher Polk / Getty Images, CBS

    Cat, aka the Black Widow Killer, is a psychopathic serial killer and hitwoman who has a keen interest is Dr. Spencer Reid in Seasons 11 and 12.

    Where you know Aubrey from: Parks and Recreation, Ingrid Goes West, and Legion.

    2. Jennifer Love-Hewitt as SSA Kate Callahan

    Frazer Harrison / Getty Images

    Kate is a supervisory special agent who joined the BAU during Season 10.

    Where you know Jennifer from: Ghost Whisperer, Party of Five, and 9-1-1.

    3. Jane Lynch as Diana Reid

    Jamie Mccarthy / Getty Images, CBS

    Diana is the mother of Dr. Reid.

    Where you know Jane from: Glee, Two and a Half Men, and The 40-Year-Old Virgin.

    4. Cameron Monaghan as Jefferey Charles

    Michael Kovac / Getty Images, CBS

    Jeffrey is a child serial killer who appears in the episode "The Boogeyman."

    Where you know Cameron from: Shameless, Gotham, and Malcolm in the Middle.

    5. Forest Whitaker as Sam Cooper

    Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images, CBS

    Sam is the leader of the BAU's Red Cell team.

    Where you know Forest from: Phone Booth, The Butler, and Black Panther.

    6. James Van Der Beek as Tobias Hankel

    John Sciulli / Getty Images, CBS

    Tobias is a delusional serial killer who appeared in the episodes "The Big Game" and "Revelations."

    Where you know James from: Dawson's Creek, Don't Trust The B**** in Apartment 23, and Varsity Blues.

    7. Elle Fanning as Tracy Belle

    Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images, CBS

    Tracy is a victim who Jeffrey (Cameron Monaghan) attempted to kill in "The Boogeyman."

    Where you know Elle from: Maleficent, Teen Spirit, and Super 8.

    8. Frankie Muniz as Jonny McHale

    Frederick M. Brown / Getty Images, CBS

    Jonny is a vigilante-turned-spree-killer who appeared in the episode "True Night."

    Where you know Frankie from: Malcolm in the Middle, Big Fat Liar, and Agent Cody Banks.

    9. Jason Alexander as Henry Grace

    Michael Loccisano / Getty Images, CBS

    Henry was a serial killer who appeared in the episode "Masterpiece."

    Where you know him from: Pretty Woman, Seinfeld, and The Grinder.

    10. Bellamy Young as Beth Clemmons

    Frederick M. Brown / Getty Images, CBS

    Beth was the love interest of SSA Aaron Hotchner during Seasons 7 and 8.

    Where you know Bellamy from: Scandal, Prodigal Son, and A Wrinkle in Time.

    11. Gina Torres as Thea Salinas

    Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images, CBS

    Thea is a detective who assisted the BAU in the episode "Normal."

    Where you know Gina from: Suits, Firefly, and Riverdale.

    12. Michelle Trachtenberg as Diane Turner

    Stephen Lovekin / Getty Images, CBS

    Diane was the stalker and murderer of Dr. Reid's girlfriend who appeared in the episode "Zugzwang."

    Where you know Michelle from: Gossip Girl, Ice Princess, and Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

    13. Mark Hamill as John Curtis

    Frazer Harrison / Getty Images, CBS

    John, aka the Replicator, was the infamous copycat serial killer who tormented the BAU throughout Season 8.

    Where you know Mark from: Star Wars.

    14. Amber Stevens West as Joy Struthers

    Gregg Deguire / Getty Images, CBS

    Joy is the daughter of SSA David Rossi.

    Where you know Joy from: Greek, 22 Jump Street, and Fired Up!

    15. Aaron Paul as Mike Zizzo

    Frazer Harrison / Getty Images, CBS

    Mike was a suspect in the episode "The Popular Kids."

    Where you know Aaron from: Breaking Bad, BoJack Horseman, and The Path.

    16. Mandy Patinkin as SSA Jason Gideon

    Frazer Harrison / Getty Images

    SSA Gideon was the head of the BAU during Seasons 1–3.

    Where you know Mandy from: The Princess Bride, Homeland, and Life Itself.

    17. Ben Savage as SSA Jason Gideon (flashback)

    Rob Kim / Getty Images, CBS

    Where you know Ben from: Boy Meets World and Girl Meets World.

    18. Daryl Sabara as Kevin Rose

    Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images, CBS

    Kevin is a young boy involved in child pornography who appeared in the episode "P911."

    Where you know Daryl from: Spy Kids and Weeds.

    19. Tony Todd as Eric Miller

    Frazer Harrison / Getty Images, CBS

    Eric is a suspect of the BAU's who appears in the episode "The Fox."

    Where you know Tony from: Final Destination, Candyman, and Chuck.

    20. Jackson Rathbone as Adam Jackson

    Jason Merritt / Getty Images, CBS

    Adam is a serial rapist and murderer who appears in the episode "Conflicted."

    Where you know Jackson from: The Twilight Saga and Finding Carter.

    21. Amber Heard as Lila Archer

    Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images, CBS

    Lila was a love interests of Dr. Reid in Season 1.

    Where you know Amber from: Never Back Down, Aquaman, and The Danish Girl.

    22. Evan Peters as Charlie Hillridge

    Matt Winkelmeyer / Getty Images, CBS

    Charlie was abducted as a child and forced into being an unwilling accomplice in the episode "Mosley Lane."

    Where you know Evan from: American Horror Story, One Tree Hill, and X-Men: Days of Futures Past.

    23. Mark Pellegrino as Lieutenant Evans

    Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images, CBS

    Lieutenant Evans is a Phoenix-based cop who assists the BAU with a case.

    Where you know Mark from: Supernatural, 13 Reasons Why, and Lost.

    24. Tim Curry as Billy Flynn

    Kevin Winter, CBS

    Billy, aka the Prince of Darkness, was a serial killer and rapist from Season 5–6.

    Where you know Tim from: Rocky Horror Picture Show, It, and The Wild Thornberrys.

    25. C. Thomas Howell as George Foyet

    Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images, CBS

    George, aka the Reaper, was a prolific serial killer who terrorized the BAU, but specifically Hotch.

    Where you know C. Thomas from: Southland, Red Dawn, and The Outsiders.

    26. Finally, Anton Yelchin as Nathan Harris

    Pascal Le Segretain / Getty Images, CBS

    Nathan was a suspect who appeared in the episode "Sex, Birth, Death."

    Where you know Anton from: Charlie Bartlett, Thoroughbreds, and Star Trek.

    BuzzFeed Daily

    Keep up with the latest daily buzz with the BuzzFeed Daily newsletter!

    Newsletter signup form