Skip To Content
    Updated on Jun 14, 2019. Posted on Mar 24, 2017

    What Iconic '90s Teen Heartthrobs Look Like Today

    The golden era of middle parts and frosted tips.

    1. Jonathan Taylor Thomas

    Getty Images
    Craig Sjodin / Getty Images

    Then: Was EVERYWHERE in the late '90s. You couldn't escape him.

    Now: Could release an album titled Me. I Am JTT... The Elusive Thespian, ’cause he has basically left the public's eye (the "now" photo is from 2013).

    2. Joshua Jackson

    Getty Images
    Michael Loccisano / Getty Image

    Then: Stole your heart as Pacey on Dawson's Creek.

    Now: Currently starring on Showtime's The Affair, which is also probably the title of the fantasy you're having about Joshua right now.

    3. Hanson

    Brenda Chase / Getty Images
    Taylor Hanson/ instagram.com

    Then: Were literally a bunch of kids.

    Now: Are currently embarking on a tour in honor of the band's 25th anniversary and the 20th anniversary of their album Middle of Nowhere. (I'm sure you sprouted a gray hair just reading that.)

    4. Freddie Prinze Jr.

    Scott Gries / Scott Gries/Imagedirect
    Theo Wargo / Getty Images for NBC

    Then: Starred in a bunch of classic teen movies.

    Now: Stars as the voice of Kanan Jarrus on Star Wars Rebels (an already classic animated series).

    5. Jared Leto

    Abc Photo Archives / Getty Images
    Chris Jackson / Getty Images

    Then: Played bad boy Jordan Catalano on My So-Called Life.

    Now: Is an ageless vampire and could still play a teenage Jordan Catalano.

    6. Luke Perry

    Diane Freed / Getty Images
    Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty Images

    Then: Played the rebel heartthrob of West Beverly High on Beverly Hills, 90210.

    Now: Plays the dad of heartthrob and wannabe rebel Archie on Riverdale.

    7. Joseph Gordon-Levitt

    NBC / Getty Images
    Carlos Alvarez / Getty Images

    Then: Was the kid from 3rd Rock from the Sun with the epic middle part.

    Now: Ditched the middle part and is now an even BIGGER star.

    8. Andrew Keegan

    Time & Life Pictures / Getty Images
    Michael Kovac / Getty Images for AltaMed

    Then: Starred in tween/teen classics 10 Things I Hate About You, 7th Heaven, and Party of Five.

    Now: Started his own religion.

    9. Jason Priestley

    Time & Life Pictures / Getty Images
    Ethan Miller / Getty Images

    Then: Played goody two-shoes Brandon Walsh on Beverly Hills, 90210.

    Now: Is working on the upcoming series Private Eyes.

    10. Mario Lopez

    NBC / Getty Images
    Frazer Harrison / Getty Image

    Then: Said the word "preppy" a lot on Saved by the Bell.

    Now: The peppy host of Extra.

    11. Mark-Paul Gosselaar

    NBC / Getty Images
    Allen Berezovsky / Getty Images

    Then: Was a stereotypical blonde California surfer dude.

    Now: Basically turned into a lumberjack.

    12. Usher

    Ron Galella / WireImage
    Mike Coppola / Getty Images

    Then: Was the baby-faced singer that made teenage girls' pulses rise.

    Now: Still making pulses rise.

    13. Devon Sawa

    Ron Galella / WireImage
    Fred Hayes / Getty Images

    Then: Earrings, a middle part, and embraced by girls who loved Casper.

    Now: Ditched the earrings and middle part and embraced leather.

    14. Scott Wolf

    Brenda Chase / Getty Images
    Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images

    Then: Looked like Tom Cruise.

    Now: Still looks like Tom Cruise.

    15. Erik von Detten

    Time & Life Pictures / Getty Images
    Michael Tulberg / Getty Images

    Then: Twink!

    Now: Dad!

    16. Rider Strong

    Time & Life Pictures / Getty Images
    Matt Winkelmeyer / Getty Images

    Then: Was Shawn on Boy Meets World.

    Now: Was Uncle Shawn on Girl Meets World.

    17. Ethan Embry

    Ron Galella / WireImage
    CHRIS DELMAS/AFP / Getty Images

    Then: Starred opposite ’90s teen icon Jennifer Love Hewitt in Can't Hardly Wait.

    Now: Stars opposite LIVING TREASURES and ICONS Jane Fonda and Lily Tomlin on Grace and Frankie.

    18. Matthew Lawrence

    Ron Galella, Ltd. / WireImage
    Matthew Lawrence. instagram.com

    Then: Was one of the Lawrence brothers.

    Now: Determined by BuzzFeed to be the best Lawrence brother. Sorry, Joey and Andrew.

    19. Leonardo DiCaprio

    Stewart Cook / Getty Images
    Mike Windle / Getty Images

    Then: Great up-and-coming actor who dated twentysomething models.

    Now: Great actor who dates twentysomething models.

    20. Will Smith

    Nbc / Getty Images
    @Tony Barnett/ youtube.com

    Then: Was a rapper turned sitcom actor.

    Now: Turning into Uncle Phil!

    CORRECTION

    OMG! In a previous version of this post we misspelled Freddie Prinze Jr.'s name.

    Nostalgia Trip

    Take a trip down memory lane that’ll make you feel nostalgia AF

    Newsletter signup form