Skip To Content

    17 Extremely Weird Thrift Store And Garage Sale Items That People Actually Found

    Poop journal, slightly used: price unknown.

    Garage sales are magical places. Sometimes you find a great deal. Sometimes you find an old Sega Dreamcast stuffed with doll hair.

    That's why the redditors over at WTFGaragesale are sharing the weirdest, creepiest, most WTF stuff they've ever found at a garage sale/thrift store/Facebook Marketplace/whatever. Here are some of the best items:

    1. Crocheted frog with boobs, $1:

    2. Poop journal, price unknown:

    3. Wood block with 5,000 coats of paint on it, $3:

    4. Privacy door hanger for newlyweds that inexplicably has CHILDREN on it, 99 cents:

    5. Vintage letter concerning a urine test, framed, $5:

    6. Painting of Jesus playing soccer, price unknown:

    7. Painting of Satan taking a dump, price unknown:

    8. Tinfoil hat for paranoid cats, 59 cents:

    9. Terrifying baby statues, various prices:

    10. Pile of carp, $1:

    11. Seashells with googly eyes playing cards, $5:

    12. Resin-cast Will Ferrell photo, 25 cents:

    13. Fire Elsa, price unknown:

    14. Chair made entirely of tennis balls, $200:

    15. Emphatic chips-and-dip plate, $2:

    16. Psychology book with inexplicable cover art, price unknown:

    17. Painting of giant birds with laser beam eyes, $50: