Carly was in total shock, understandably. "Are you crazy? I don't know what to do," she cried, before kissing Jeff.
Their friends were also surprised: They had no idea they were going to a wedding until they arrived.
The wedding was a small, outside ceremony, and pretty much perfect.
"I promise to laugh with you and cry with you... as long as we both shall live."
Talk about a coming-home party.