Jordana Easyliner. They are my favorite automatic eyeliners. “Coffee Bean” is my go-to boring work eyeliner, and it is the perfect brown. Their neutrals are just great - soft, blendable, and totally matte. They have a new color called “Khaki” that is a really good, non-metallic, non-glitter gray. They all go on super smooth and wear well, but are still easy to take off at night.
For crazy colored eyeliner, I am loving the Sally Girl eyeliners from Sally Beauty Supply. They are $.99 (less if you have a Sally Club Card). They are short, but who really needs a full length fuchsia eyeliner? They come in tons of fun colors that are usually hard to find at that price point, such as the aforementioned fuchsia, orange, yellow, lime green, etc.