Skip To Content

    "Pretty Little Liars" Has A Million Plots, But These 19 Almost Made People Give Up The Show Forever

    Honestly, half of this show felt like a fever dream!

    We asked members of the BuzzFeed Community which Pretty Little Liars plots annoyed them so much they almost stopped watching the show. Here are some of the best responses.

    🚨SPOILERS AHEAD.🚨

    1. When Toby ate Spencer's weed gummies and got too high to help catch A.

    Toby passing out while trying to catch A with Jason, Spencer, Aria, Emily, and Hanna
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "It felt so corny and out of place. It was also really degrading to Toby's character. I didn't know whether to laugh or cringe."

    annabethanie

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    2. When Adam Lambert randomly sang at the Halloween school party on a train.

    The liars watching Adam Lambert sing at the Halloween train party.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    "That was enough for me. I think I would have fallen off eventually but something about that whole dynamic was so incomprehensible and contrived I just quietly submitted my resignation and peaced out."

    jttcangetit

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    3. When A trapped the girls in a dollhouse that was an exact replica of their houses.

    Hanna, Mona, Aria, Spencer, and Emily looking at the camera A set up in the dollhouse.
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "The idea of the dollhouse itself was pretty unbelievable. Like how would Cece manage to create a house which had replicas of each of the girls' rooms and all the other weird stuff about it? It was kinda bananas."

    kal63

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    4. When Aria focused more on her chaotic love life than on herself.

    Aria and Ezra at the alter on their wedding day.
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "She and Ezra dated secretly but she pretended to date Holden. She and Ezra broke up so she dated her self-defense teacher, left him for Ezra, broke up with Ezra again, slept with a random college guy, got back with Ezra a few more times, had a few hookups with Jason, got engaged to the book guy, then married Ezra. Girl needed time to love herself first!"

    aramanthe

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    5. When Spencer and Caleb started dating and betrayed so many of their friends.

    Spencer and Caleb kissing.
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "I hated when Caleb and Spencer got together...it was an absolute betrayal to a friend and ex."

    idkwhy8373762

    Watch scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    6. When Maya was killed by her stalker and they found her dead body behind Alison's house!

    Emily, Spencer, Aria, and Hanna crying as the police bring out Maya's dead body.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    7. When Spencer and Toby broke up over their pregnancy scare.

    Spencer and Toby sitting across the room from each other while waiting for the results of the pregnancy test
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "Spencer and Toby breaking up over the dumbest reason was so out of character for both of them tbh."

    carysmcguckin

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    8. When it was revealed that Alison had been inseminated with Emily's stolen eggs using sperm from Wren.

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    Specifically at 1:05 -1:21

    9. When Alison returned from the dead.

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    "The flashbacks made her seem like an interesting, complex antagonist and then she came back and is just really bland. It was a really big let down."

    paigecampbell1

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    10. When Cece was revealed to be A and Alison's sister, who had tortured the girls for seeming glad Ali had disappeared.

    Aria, Spencer, Mona, Emily, and Hanna seeing Cece be revealed as A.
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    11. When the show made relationships between underage students and adults look like the ultimate couple goals.

    Aria looking at Ezra and asking him on a date while they are in a classroom.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    "When I started watching this show at 17, it seemed so romantic. Now I can see it for what it is, which is creepy and problematic AF."

    miscblogger92

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    12. When Emily still dated Paige after Paige tried to drown her.

    Paige holding Emily underwater in an attempt to drown her.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    13. When the show had a huge, confusing time jump.

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "I was already confused AF but that season had me questioning my whole life."

    mayahazel

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    14. When Aria became A in an effort to protect Ezra from going to jail.

    Aria wearing a black hoodie standing outside in the dark.
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "I genuinely stopped watching after that."

    tdhairyawangroup8

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    15. When Ezra was revealed to be writing a book about the girls.

    Aria finding Ezra's book and reading pages of it.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    "Just bullshit. They shouldn’t have been dating in the first place but that revelation retroactively ruined the first couple of seasons when the show actually made sense."

    germancanadian

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    16. When Spencer was lusting after all her sister's boyfriends.

    Melissa watching Spencer and Wren kiss in Spencer's bedroom.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    17. When they realized Ian was framed and set the whole mission to discover A back 10 steps.

    Ian looking shocked right before A pushes him off the ledge killing him.
    ABC Family / Via youtube.com

    "It pissed me off so much that the entirety of Season 1 was for nothing and it was very clear they had no idea what the fuck they were doing long term."

    surfingrockets

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    18. Sara Harvey's entire plot on the show.

    Sara Harvey sitting in the back of a limo dressed as the Black Widow.
    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "They never explained WTF her involvement was really about."

    rebeccamainwaring

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    19. And finally, Spencer having a secret British twin.

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    "Spencer’s twin sister and that AWFUL British accent just ruined the whole show for me."

    sophiesmith3

    Watch the scene here:

    View this video on YouTube

    Freeform / Via youtube.com

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form