Skip To Content

    These Guys Guessed Which Makeup Was Their Girlfriends And It Was Fuckin' Cute

    "I feel like the kid who wasn't prepared for the pop quiz."

    by ,

    We decided to have boyfriends guess which makeup bag belonged to their girlfriends based on the products each girl uses. Fun fact: we removed their foundation to make it even harder! Meet the three brave couples:

    View this video on YouTube

    BuzzFeedYellow / Via YouTube

    First up, we had Steven and Jen, who've been dating for four years. You'd think Steve would be a pro at Jen's makeup by now.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Safiya and Tyler also gave it a go. They've been dating for 1.5 years, which is enough time to know your partners taste and preferences.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Freddie and Paul also got in on the challenge. They've been dating for six months, which in Los Angeles is basically a lifetime.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Jen was pretty confident that her stuff would be obvious.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Pure fear in Steve's eyes. GULP.

    While Saf was very understanding that it was likely Tyler would fail.

    BuzzFeed Video

    To make things extra challenging we threw in a rando bag. Let the guessing games begin!

    BuzzFeed Video

    We were one step ahead of the dudes, who were, "gonna rely pretty heavily on the bag itself."

    BuzzFeed Video

    Sorry, Ty.

    Steve seemed to think that Jen doesn't spend a ton of time on her everyday makeup.

    Buzzfeed Video

    Tyler was into brand names. He knew Saf was raving about Kylie Jenner's lip products.

    BuzzFeed Video

    LOOK AT YOU GO, BOY.

    And Paul knew that Freddie does not love every color in the rainbow equally.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Steven relied on his basic instincts…it was kinda like he had a sixth sense for sniffing out Jen’s makeup.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Things got realll tricky when Tyler and Paul narrowed it down to either Saf's or Fred's makeup bags. Turns out BFFs really do have ALL the same interests.

    BuzzFeed Video
    BuzzFeed Video

    It was close...but in the end...

    BuzzFeed Video

    ...THEY ALL GOT IT RIGHT!

    BuzzFeed Video

    And Tyler broke his streak of "failing at BuzzFeed competitions."

    BuzzFeed Video

    AYYY!

    Not gonna lie, I'm super impressed. All three gentleman were actually invested in their girlfriends' product preferences and beauty habits, and it showed through their thoughtful guessing.

    BuzzFeed Video

    This video also served as a healthy reminder that I'm forever alone.

    NBC / Via Giphy

    BuzzFeed Daily

    Keep up with the latest daily buzz with the BuzzFeed Daily newsletter!

    Newsletter signup form