We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
1. A Carhartt cuffed beanie over 115,000 reviewers (yes, you read that right!) are OBSESSED with for its soft, 100% cotton material that's lightweight, but still warm enough to keep your head cozy.
For the best care, these should be hand-washed only.
Promising review: "I’m obsessed! The perfect color and also super comfortable. For me, it does fit a bit snug, but I like that. It keeps my head really warm, which is obviously important in a beanie! It easily goes with any outfit and I’ve gotten so many compliments on it." —Alexandra jennings
Get it from Amazon for $19.99 (available in 34 colors).
2. A waffle-knit beanie made with organically grown cotton the planet AND your noggin' will thank you for once you throw this softie on for size.
3. A recycled cotton beanie from Madewell giving off vibes *so* casual you can easily pair it with a jean jacket or shacket.
Promising review: "Immediately fell in love with this hat. The recycled cotton is very comfortable and retains its shape. It's the perfect amount of slouch vs. fold and a great mid-weight beanie for fall/winter/spring. After I purchased my first one, I bought two more in different colors to keep on rotation!" —AngieT15
Get it from Madewell for $35 (available in nine colors).
4. A ponytail-friendly beanie offered in 64 colors and designed with a stretchy opening on top so you can keep your hair off your neck *without* having to settle for pairing your outfit to your hat.
The material is made from 100% acrylic material that's machine-washable.
Promising review: "I have very big curly hair, so I could never find one of these that fit well — they just didn’t look right. I love this hat! It’s so easy to wear and it goes with everything. I just pull my big pony or bun through and it sits in the same spot the whole time!" —Kindle Customer
Get it from Amazon for $14.99 (available in 64 colors and two and three packs).
Keep your noggin' looking ~fresh~ with these bucket hats we found, too.
5. A Nike embroidered beanie made from 100% Dri-FIT fabric to keep your melon comfy and dry rain or shine.
Promising review: "I got this for my boyfriend for Christmas and he wears it all the time, with everything. It's super soft, good quality, and versatile!" —caroline adkins
Get it from Amazon for $19.95+ (available in seven colors).
6. A chunky knit beanie in 171 colors (!!!) featuring a stretchy material to keep your skull as snug as a bug in a rug 🐛.
The 100% acrylic material should be hand-washed only.
Promising review: "I have bought six of these! I just lost three in the past few months, so have to buy a few more! I do a lot of outdoor work and wear them all the time. I still have my original that is 7-years-old, and NONE have ever fallen apart — and I have washed them in the washing machine multiple times!" —Ashley
Get it from Amazon for $14.99 (available in 171 colors).
7. A Dickies acrylic beanie for a laidback skater look at a moment's notice.
It's made with 100% acrylic material that's machine-washable.
Promising review: "Of all the beanies I have, these keep my head the warmest. They are the thickest and best-insulated beanies I have. Works great for when it's really cold." —tisane
Get it from Amazon for $16.99 (available in 15 colors).
Looking for something to pair it with? We've got these trendy fall coats and jackets.
8. A beanie with a faux fur pom-pom that's detachable so you can go from snuggly to casual vibes in a ~snap~.
The pom-pom should be placed in a laundry bag before being put into the washer; beanie should only be hand-washed.
Promising review: "This hat was absolutely perfect! I loved how you could detach the fur ball so that the hat could be used in different ways. It was very comfortable and super cute on! Also kept me very warm, which was a plus." —Ashley Krivda
Get it from Amazon for $16.99+ (available in 24 colors).
9. A wide-cuff L.L. Bean beanie providing stretch and ultimate comfort without leaving those annoying red marks on your forehead.
Each color features a different unique patch.
Promising review: "Bought one for my husband and myself, and we love them. The extra wide cuff is perfect for covering your ears with a double layer. The hat feels lightweight, but we've been wearing them for a few weeks and they keep us warm. Fit is just right, not too tight but tight enough to stay in place." —SMag
Get it from L.L. Bean for $19.99+ (available in seven colors).
10. A hand-knit cupcake-shaped beanie that'll be a nice ~treat~ for your head. It'll provide comfort AND insulation that'll feel pretty sweet during the cold months.
Stella's Knits is a small shop on Etsy located in Bedford, Virginia, that creates handmade knit hats, apparel, and accessories for babies, kids, and adults.
Promising review: "I have ordered MANY hats from this wonderful seller and they are always sent promptly, made so well, and are just plain ADORABLE. I have bought them for all ages from new babies to adults! Thank you SOOOO much, once again." —ravenleilu
Get it from Stella's Knits on Etsy for $15 (available in seven sizes).
11. A Skims polyester beanie *so* ridiculously fuzzy, it'll be like wearing a pillow...but on your head.
For the best care, hand wash in cold water with similar colors and do not throw in the dryer.
Promising review: "Imagine a teddy bear cuddling your head! The most amazing beanies I’ve ever owned! I have every color and plan on getting the same for all my kids! You won’t be disappointed! Even the colors are lit! Definitely a win!" —Candi K
Get it from Skims for $28 (available in four colors).
12. A brain knit beanie for showing off your ~brainy~ side while adding a little humor and funkiness to your wardrobe.
Promising review: "Who knew that anyone needed a brain hat? Well, if you decide you do this one is great. It seems to be well-made and really does look like a brain — right color pink and everything. A little wacky, perhaps, but some days you just need a laugh (especially in the depths of winter)." —Jane Jetson
Get it from Amazon for $29.99.
13. A beanie with built-in goggles your eyes will high-five you for — especially the next time you're shoveling your driveway on a windy snowy day.
The glasses are also removable to transition it to a normal beanie look.
Promising review: "This is a cool hat and it’s lined with faux fur for extra warmth (I wasn’t expecting that). On snowy days in Chicago, this is a must; it's super convenient. While I may look foolish, who cares when it’s 12 degrees with snow blowing all over the place and you can’t keep your eyes open. This is for sure a staple!!!" —Diamond Girl
Get it from Amazon for $14.99 (available in seven colors).
14. A fleece-lined beanie whose soft interior and exterior will completely top any accessory your pair it with.
The 100% acrylic material should be dry-cleaned or hand-washed.
Promising review: "This beanie went with me everywhere this winter. If it wasn’t on my head it was in my purse. I love the slouchiness of it, it’s very warm, the inside is a soft velour, it’s well made and durable, and it stretches to fit any size head. I plan to purchase this in additional colors for next winter." —Elizabeth
Get it from Amazon for $16.99 (available in 24 colors).
15. A beanie with a built-in scarf for keeping your neck and noggin' cozy, minus the hassle of scarf ends getting tangled up.
Promising review: "I liked this so much I ordered another one. It's the warmest hat I ever owned. It keeps the wind and cold out completely, and keeps your ears and neck warm. It's a hat and scarf all in one. Also, the visor keeps the sun out of your eyes so don't need sunglasses in winter." —Jane
Get it from Amazon for $20.99+ (available in 13 colors).
16. A ribbed acrylic knit tie dye beanie — your proceeds will go toward supporting national parks, so you can do good while looking good.
17. A double pom-pom beanie lined with fleece and a windproof material that will completely ~blow you away~ over how comfortable it is.
Promising review: "I absolutely adore this hat; it’s super comfortable and definitely keeps you warm. It covers my entire head no matter what I do with my hair! A lot of people like it, and the pom-poms make them smile." —Nani Moore
Get it from Amazon for $15.99+ (available in 23 colors).
18. A custom leather patch beanie for adding a touch of sleekness that's uniquely your own and decorated with a name, place, date — whatever you want!
Welsh Mtn Co. is a small shop on Etsy located in Narvon, Pennsylvania, that specializes in creating handcrafted leather goods and accessories.
Promising review: "Hat is perfect and the designer worked with us to get our custom design just right. Super soft and great quality!" —Colleen Weingarten
Get it from Welsh Mtn Co. on Etsy for $25.95 (available in three colors, two patch sizes, and two patch colors).
19. An eye embroidered knit beanie you'll be saying "eye love you" to once the snuggly acrylic material touches your mitts.
Goldenbeets is a woman-owned small shop on Etsy located in Philadelphia that creates bakery-inspired accessories and apparel.
Promising review: "MY FAV BEANIE EVER!!! Normally eye don't look good with beanies unless it's a certain type of knit, but this knit is well made and flexible!!! It's warm, comfy, and it looks AWESOME!" —Amy D
Get it from Goldenbeets on Etsy for $18.20+ (available in eight colors and with or without a mask).
20. A leopard print beanie exuding chic vibes and a slouchy back you'll happily want to be ~spotted~ in.
21. A wool-lined mohawk beanie giving you a fresh frunky 'do to rock and keep your head feeling snuggly.
22. A knit slouchy beanie that'll proclaim exactly how you feel about cold weather — and evoke chuckles from anyone who gets a peek at your winter 'fit.
Promising review: "Whenever my husband wears this hat in public, people smile and comment on it. He loves this hat because it's funny, warm, and comfortable. He lives in beanies and this has become his favorite! He works outside in our cold Northwest weather, and wears this hat nearly every day. When it rains, he switches to another beanie when he gets to work so that it doesn't get wet, then puts this one on as soon as he gets back in the car! Don't hesitate, you won't regret buying this one!" —katrina
Get it from Amazon for $10.99.
23. An Everlane organic cotton beanie — it'll have you ~lining~ up outfits that would pair perfectly just so you have an excuse to wear it everyday.
Make sure to hand-wash this in cold water and lay flat to dry.
Promising review: "I'm in love with this hat! Great color, great fit. I usually feel that hats are too constricting for my curls, but I love the way this one fits." —Cora4grace
Get it from Everlane for $14 (originally $48).
24. A crochet cow beanie, which will say "moo-ve over" to your basic hats as you grab this to wear out AGAIN.
Gilly's Handmade Crafts is a small shop on Etsy located in Wigan, United Kingdom, that creates handmade unique crochet beanies.
Promising review: "I absolutely adore this beanie and get lots of compliments on it. 100% recommend this — it's really adorable and great quality, will be buying more in the future!" —Leslie
Get it from Gilly's Handmade Crafts on Etsy for $26.21.
25. A broken heart embroidered beanie you won't be able to help but love for its quick ability to shield your ears from that bone-chilling wind.
The 100% acrylic material should be hand washed only.
Promising review: "Fits without problem, not tight at all, and looks really, really, really good. Even after sweat, grime, and every other form of dirt getting into it, it seems to still work and not stain like others I've had from here. The stitching is solid to the point I've gotten things hooked on it, and it pulls out without damaging the beanie in any capacity. Over all of the quality of this thing, and the way it fits, it's a definite must purchase." —Dale Spearman
Get it from Amazon for $16.99 (available in seven colors).
Let's not forget that it would also look fab with a black jean jacket.
26. A custom embroidered beanie for showcasing your brand, name, favorite saying, etc. The options are quite literally limitless AND the cuff is adjustable to personalize it even more to your style.
Parvous Boutique is a small shop on Etsy that makes custom embroidered apparel and accessories. Make sure to type your personalization into the box below the dropdown menus before adding it to your cart.
Promising review: "The quality is very good and comfortable. The beanie was definitely as expected and the seller is very nice and very helpful to make my design come alive. I LOVE IT." —Lorenzo
Get it from Parvous Boutique on Etsy for $19.99+ (available in 30 colors and two embroidery types).
27. A teddy bear beanie you'll consider a bear necessity for keeping your melon warm and adorable.
Promising review: "I absolutely love this beanie! The ears are so cute; plus, they actually stay up when you wear it." —Musicalways18
Get it from Hot Topic for $13.52.
What you *won't* be looking like once those temps fall:
Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!
The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.