People Think Eddie Redmayne Implied His Film Made Trans Issues Mainstream

Update: Eddie Redmayne told BuzzFeed News he hopes his comment wasn’t misunderstood, and that he acknowledges that countless others led trans issues into the mainstream media.

On Sunday evening, Redmayne attended the BAFTA Awards in London, where he lost out in the Best Actor award to Leonardo DiCaprio, who won for his role in The Revenant.

Robyn Beck / AFP / Getty Images

Redmayne was nominated for his lead role in The Danish Girl. The movie is based on the real-life story of trans woman Lili Elbe, one of the earliest recipients of gender affirmation surgery.

Working Title Films / United Kingdom

On the evening of the awards show, Redmayne spoke to BBC News, which tweeted that the actor said it was “extraordinary” how trans issues have come into mainstream media following The Danish Girl.

Twitter: @BBCNewsEnts

In the full interview with the BBC, Redmayne also speaks about how he was fortunate that many trans women were “incredibly generous” in educating him when he was preparing for the role.

He adds that although its been 100 years since Elbe’s story, he believes that there is still a long way to go for trans rights, and that hopefully the film “helps encourage” the conversation.

Redmayne’s comments have since been criticised by many in the trans community who believe the actor is implying his movie is responsible for trans issues being covered in the media.

@BBCNewsEnts Lucky for all those trans activists working tirelessly on this issue for decades that you decided to make a film then huh

— Landers (@LA_Anders)

Some noted that trans people “existed before” the movie, and said they had been campaigning for trans rights to be brought into the mainstream for decades.

Someone tell Eddie Redmayne that trans women existed for some time before The Danish Girl and can speak for themselves better than he can.

— angry slice of pie (@theviciouspixie)

*Eddie Redmayne notices trans people exist* Redmayne: Thank god I saved you. https://t.co/Pi9QfKg3tz

— Jayme Allen (@electricalwell)

Others were critical of Hollywood for not casting trans people as trans characters in movies.

No offense Eddie but I think a lot of those issues are about how Hollywood won't cast trans ppl as trans ppl https://t.co/rPuLYJeVUS

— Darth Darth Binks (@OfficialSadBeep)

🙅🏽Eddie, don't take our opportunities to represent ourselves away from us. Don't let cis-dudes rep trans women‼️.. 🚷 https://t.co/0vHsv77eV7

— ♡⚧I'mMySpectrum⚧♡ (@Billvall84)

Some people said Redmayne’s comments were taken out of context, especially given that he’s been outspoken on the subject of transgender issues since his casting in The Danish Girl.

I wish trans people would stop slagging Eddie Redmayne off. I know he's not perfect but he's fighting our corner, FFS!

— Andie Pas de Deux (@andiepasdedeux)

In previous interviews, Redmayne has said people need to be “urgently” educated on trans issues and that trans women “constantly” face judgement and discrimination.

“I fell into all the clichés of ignorance,” Redmayne said to Entertainment Weekly last November, speaking about trans issues. “I didn’t realize that gender and sexuality weren’t related. I confused the terms transvestitism and transgender. But what’s lovely is, the second you understand the difference, you see how gigantic it is and how important it is that we educate ourselves.”

Others defended Redmayne for having good intentions when it came to highlighting trans issues, but said he’s still “catching up”.

You may have meant well Eddie, but trans issues were well ahead and mainstream before The Danish Girl. You're just catching up. Welcome.

— Candy (@CandeyQ)

I don't think it's Eddie Redmayne's fault though it's quite obvious he knew nothing about trans issues

— Uncle Phil (@IdiosyncraticXL)

Redmayne’s comment prompted some people to mock the actor for suggesting the movie was a turning point for trans issues.

"It's astonishing how rail nationalisation has come onto the agenda since we made the Thomas The Tank Engine movie" https://t.co/zMDVemW0SF

— Primly Stable (@PrimlyStable)

Remember how homosexuality wasn't a thing until Tom Hanks did Philadelphia? https://t.co/I9HIY3Q9RP

— Dean Burnett (@garwboy)

"Also, since I did The Theory of Everything, I've noticed that quite a lot of buildings have ramps now." https://t.co/RoJoclG1st

— Al Kennedy (@housetoastonish)

Eddie Redmayne has done for trans rights what Macklemore did for marriage equality, thank you, blessed cis-white male saviors

— Erin Quinn (@mserinquinn)

Kat Blaque, a transgender vlogger, told BuzzFeed News she wants people like Redmayne to speak up for the trans community, but not to “speak for them”, and said his comment reflects “vanity and privilege”.

YouTube

Blaque said actors who play trans roles believe their work is “important, groundbreaking, even radical”, but that in reality casting trans people in Hollywood movies would be the more radical move.

She said the reception to Danish Girl is “being sold” as a movie that will make change for the trans community, but that she and many other trans people don’t see it that way.

“I think that Hollywood needs to stop pretending that trans actors don’t exist,” she said. “Trans actors not only exist, but they’re in need of work. When you cast a cis character in a trans role, you’re essentially taking roles that were written for them away from them.”

Blaque believes that regardless of whether or not Redmayne’s comment was misinterpreted, he should be “trying his best” to listen to the trans community.

“There’s a part of me that cannot fully blame him,” Blaque said, “as while the trans community is incredibly helpful among each other, we still have very mixed emotions when giving cis people access to these conversations.

“Cis allies are a very important part of trans progress, but we need them to listen, not speak over us. Maybe it was a slip-up – I can buy that, maybe. However, to me, if you’re going to be a cis person playing a trans role, try your best to not make it worse.”

UPDATE: Eddie Redmayne says he hopes his comment wasn't misunderstood, and acknowledges countless others have paved the way for trans rights to be in the mainstream media.

In a comment to BuzzFeed News, Redmayne said:

“I hope what I said was not misunderstood. In the 4 years since I started work on The Danish Girl, trans stories, lives and issues have burst into the mainstream media with people like Laverne Cox, Janet Mock, Mya Taylor, Rebecca Root, Jake Graf, Caitlyn Jenner and the countless others pushing the needle forward and making history on their own terms. As I’ve said before, it has been an honor to be part of this conversation in some small way by sharing Lili and Gerda’s story. There is still a long way to go, and allies of the trans community (including me) need to continue our support.”

Check out more articles on BuzzFeed.com!

Rossalyn Warren is a senior reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in London.
Contact Rossalyn Warren at rossalyn.warren@buzzfeed.com.
 
 

More News

More News

Now Buzzing