back to top

If You Have No Idea How The Indian Internet May Change And Why Everyone's Flipping A Shit, Read This

Here's your cheat sheet on India's net neutrality debate and how it affects you.

Posted on

Aite, first things first. To understand how the Indian internet may change, you need to understand how it works right now.

So, the way India has air and land and water, we also have invisible communication pathways in the air, divided into various spectrums.

This is a tea plantation in Kerala, btw. Nice.
Danielrao / Getty Images

This is a tea plantation in Kerala, btw. Nice.

That's why you hear people say things like "3G spectrum" and "4G spectrum". Those are basically different invisible highways in the air on which we can send and receive information.

To maintain some sort of order in the world, the government controls the rights to use these information pathways.

So telecom companies – like Airtel and Reliance and stuff – buy the rights to use those pathways from the government.

And then YOU pay those telecom companies to buy little bits of those highways. (For instance, I pay Vodafone to send and receive 12GB worth of info on those highways per month.)

Right now, you pay the telecom companies to use their data, but you can do whatever you want with that data once you've paid for it.

Via grabhouse.com

Like, you just used some of yours to watch this amazing Sunny Deol GIF and that was your decision and your telecom company and the government had nothing to do with it. (Look at your life. Look at your choices.)

So, if I pay Vodafone for 12GB a month, I can use it to shop for vintage cat posters or surf porn or study geology, and Vodafone will give me the same speed and price regardless of what I'm doing.

That promise from telecom companies – that your data's speed and price will be consistent REGARDLESS of what you're doing online – is what net neutrality is.

Here's its fancy-ass definition (thanks Google!). We put it on a stock photo so you have something to look at while you read:

Moodboard / Getty Images

OK, you just learned a lot. Take a break by enjoying this amazing GIF:

Alright. So net neutrality sounds like a good system, right? What's to freak out about, you ask? I WILL TELL YOU.

Telecom companies are really pissed that apps and services (like WhatsApp and Skype and FaceTime) use their spectrum internet highway space, and they (the telecom companies) don't make any money off it.

Thinkstock

So they went to TRAI and asked that regulations be changed such that people pay a basic amount for internet access, and then pay them EXTRA to use "Over The Top" services i.e. messaging apps, video streaming apps, etc.

I can tell I'm losing you. OK, I know. Just pretend Laddoo is a telecom company and Big B is the TRAI.

Imaan Sheikh / Via Dharma

Oh, and telecom companies are also asking for the right to strike deals WITH some of these apps and services, so those particular apps will run faster and cheaper on their network than others.

Warner Bros.

So, for example (I'm literally making this up), Vodafone could strike a deal with WhatsApp by which WhatsApp will work faster on Vodafone than any other messaging app runs on Vodafone.

Vodafone can then tell customers: if you want to use a different messaging service (let's say Viber) at a high speed like WhatsApp, you have to pay extra money. This basically allows Vodafone to bring WhatsApp more customers than Viber, and to effectively destroy the hopes of any 19-year-old in Andheri who was on the verge of inventing the coolest messaging app ever (why would you pay for his new app when you get WhatsApp for free?). It allows telecom companies to influence the success and failure of upcoming apps and services.

DOES YOUR BRAIN HURT FROM ALL OF THIS INFORMATION? Take a break by listening to this timeless classic.

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com

Bet you used to think you had the answers to everything, huh?

I know it's tough to understand. But basically, what telecom companies want to do to the internet is like:

• Rickshaws taking you to their favourite restaurants for free, but making you pay extra to go at the same speed to certain other restaurants.

• Sabzi walas charging you more for good quality tomatoes if you're cooking certain dishes and less if you're cooking others.

• Highway tolls being higher if you want to go certain restaurants, and lower if you're going to others.

(Wow apparently I'm mad hungry.)

That way of running the internet is a threat to net neutrality (i.e. telecom companies' promise to not meddle with what you do once you've paid for their data).

NBC

I feel you, Phoebz.

SO anyway. Where we're at now is: Telecom companies have asked TRAI to make these changes, and TRAI has gone, "¯\_(ツ)_/¯".

They've asked netizens to write in with their opinions by April 24th.
Dharma

They've asked netizens to write in with their opinions by April 24th.

Internet activists have been rallying people to write in to TRAI in support of net neutrality. The movement has united under the hashtag #SaveTheInternet.

All India Bakchod / Via buzzfeed.com

Celebrities have joined in, too.

More on King Khan's pro-net neutrality stance here.
Anne-christine Poujoulat / Getty Images

More on King Khan's pro-net neutrality stance here.

And India's Reddit community has been campaigning hard to preserve net neutrality as well.

#DoItForTheYouth #DoItForTheFuture #DoItForPappu

A new website called SaveTheInternet.in makes that process extremely easy, allowing users to email TRAI with a single click.

Various major brands have come forward in favour of net neutrality:

@redditindia Amazon has always supported #NetNeutrality.

NDTV supports #netneutrality. Here's what the debate is about http://t.co/AZl53ORXj0

And on Saturday night, #SaveTheInternet was India's #2 trending topic on Twitter (second only to cricket, which, obz).

Twitter

Meanwhile, Airtel has gone ahead and announced "Airtel Zero," a platform via which users will get free access to certain apps (apps that have struck deals and paid Airtel), but will have to pay for others.

If that concept sounds familiar, it's because you read about it a couple of minutes ago. Remember?

That's right. "Airtel Zero" is making a splash as a well-timed violation of net neutrality. And Flipkart has signed on.

^^^ Redditors are protesting by giving crappy reviews to Airtel and Flipkart's apps. More here.
buzzfeed.com

^^^ Redditors are protesting by giving crappy reviews to Airtel and Flipkart's apps. More here.

And a lot of people aren't thrilled about it. Here's Zomato's founder, Deepinder Goyal:

Couldn’t have built Zomato if we had a competitor on something like Airtel Zero. (1 of 2)

Calling Airtel Zero fair and not a violation of net neutrality is bs. (2 of 2)

*Wipes sweat off forehead* Lots of learning, huh? Here, relax with this GIF:

A quick recap:

Narendra Modi

Now:

IFC

Telecom companies pay government for spectrum. You pay telecom companies for data. You do whatever you want with it. Everything costs the same and is the same speed.

What people are afraid will happen if India loses net neutrality:

Via giphy.com

Telecom companies pay the government for spectrum. Apps/services pay telecom companies to operate. You pay telecom companies for data. You pay telecom companies more for certain services.

  1. So, now that you're all filled in, how do you feel about India's ongoing net neutrality debate?

    Correct
    Incorrect
    I'm desperate to #SaveTheInternet! Net neutrality is necessary!
    Correct
    Incorrect
    Ummmm pretttty alright, tbh. I don't see what the fuss is about.
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I'm confused! I see pros and cons either way!
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I still have no idea what's going on.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later
Looks like we are having a problem on the server.
So, now that you're all filled in, how do you feel about India's ongoing net neutrality debate?
  1.  
    vote votes
    I'm desperate to #SaveTheInternet! Net neutrality is necessary!
  2.  
    vote votes
    Ummmm pretttty alright, tbh. I don't see what the fuss is about.
  3.  
    vote votes
    I'm confused! I see pros and cons either way!
  4.  
    vote votes
    I still have no idea what's going on.

If you chose to #SaveTheInternet, go over here and do it.

If you're feelin' pretty chill, just hang tight and see what happens.

And if you're still confused, here's some more material that may help:
Watch All India Bakchod break down the net neutrality debate.

• And read everything there is to know about the Indian internet's fraught governance.

Finally, I leave you with a fine selection of the internet's best work:

Take it all in.

Look at this cat skydiving!

Thank you for your time.

Take quizzes and chill with the BuzzFeed app.