Season One: Tate Langdon
Season Two: Dr. Thredson/Bloodyface
Season Three: Madame Delphine LaLaurie
Season Four: Dandy Mott
Season One: Constance Langdon
Season Two: Lana Winters
Season Three: Madison Montgomery
Season Four: Twisty The Clown
Season One: Moira O'Hara
Season Two: Sister Mary Eunice
Season Three: Queenie
Season Four: Chester Creb & Marjorie
So, I wanna know! Who would you have chosen? Let me know in the comments! But as Myrtle Snow would say, "Don't be a hater, dear."