Skip To Content

    20 Unpopular "Gilmore Girls" Opinions That Every Fan Secretly Knows Are True

    "Best Gilmore love interest is OBVIOUSLY that Yale guy who listens to The Smiths while doing laundry and then rejects Rory when she asks him out. Not all heroes wear capes."

    We recently asked the BuzzFeed Community to tell us some of their unpopular opinions about Gilmore Girls. Here are some of our favorites:

    1. The "close" relationship that Lorelai and Rory share is downright creepy.

    2. And Lorelai wasn't actually a great mom after all. In fact, she was downright terrible.

    3. In fact, Dean wasn't so hot either, even though he was supposed to be the romantic, devoted one.

    4. Rory should've just accepted Logan's proposal.

    5. April was actually one of the best curveballs of the whole show.

    6. No one actually liked the Stars Hollow Musical.

    7. Lorelai was just an immature, overgrown kid.

    8. The real power couple should've been Rory and Paris.

    9. Emily Gilmore was the best Gilmore Girl of them all.

    10. Rory didn't have what it takes to be a journalist at all.

    11. The father of Rory's baby, teased in A Year in the Life, is probably the Wookie, not Logan.

    12. The ending of the Netflix revival, A Year in the Life, was actually perfect.

    13. Zach was the perfect guy and didn't deserve the hate he got.

    14. Lorelai and Rory's food habits just could not have been a real thing.

    15. Mrs. Kim and Emily Gilmore were straight-up abusive.

    16. Rory's first true love was Tristan. She just didn't know it.

    17. Paris Gellar is the LITERAL worst.

    18. Lorelai actually shouldn't have ended up with Luke OR Christopher.

    19. Or she should've ended up with Jason (aka Digger).

    20. Because, really, Luke and Lorelai were never meant to be.

    Submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.