Nina's thoughts: Hands down, the best one of the four. I always thought people were overhyping Glossier products, but this is a truly standout brow gel. It's not too rigid and the applicator makes it easy to get your lil hairs in place. If I had to buy and use a brow gel, this would be it.
Lara's thoughts: THE REAL MVP. I hate that I like this so much because it's so small and $16, but I will most definitely purchase this and use it every day of my life when I am not using Benefit. It's a great color, great texture, and it just looks natural but makes my brows look way better. I'm freakin' sold. Damnit.
Alice's thoughts: Definitely my favorite of the four. It had the best balance of hold and color. I was so happy to see that it actually made my hairs stay put! I thought maybe the color was going to come off too dark, but it looked fine once I put it on. Will definitely be adding this to my “only-got-10-minutes-to-get-ready” morning kit.
Sheridan's thoughts: Definitely my favorite, mostly because I use it every day and it works for what I need it to do. Boy Brow makes my brows stay all day without getting flaky or crunchy. It doesn't do the best job of filling in gaps, which is why I follow up with a pencil. But, if you're looking for an easy tool that'll brush your lashes and keep them in place, then this is the one for you.
Our overall rating: 5/5