Browse links
US residents can opt out of "sales" of personal data.
GREAT NEWS: Online Girl Scout cookie orders have been extended until April 30!
Shortbread – 30 calories per cookie, 1.13 grams of fat
This cookie is firm with a vanilla taste.
Trefoils – 32 calories per cookie, 1.4 grams of fat
This cookie is less firm with a more buttery flavor. However, you can taste hints of vanilla as well.
Blind taste test cookie winner with a 3–0 vote:
Trefoils
ABC Bakers S'mores – 90 calories per cookie, 4.5 grams of fat
This tastes exactly like a chocolate-covered s'more. Touché!
Little Brownie Bakers – 75 calories per cookie, 3.5 grams of fat
This doesn't really taste like a s'more. It is good, but it tastes more like a vanilla cookie with frosting inside.
Blind taste test cookie winner:
There is no winner because they are completely different cookies and they don't even have the same flavors going on! For the record, my husband and son liked the chocolate-covered s'more, but I liked the cookie sandwich one because it gave me Dunkaroos vibes.
ABC Bakers Thin Mints – 40 calories per cookie, 1.75 grams of fat
This has a smooth, minty taste and it is crisp.
Little Brownie Bakers – 40 calories per cookie, 2 grams of fat
This has a richer chocolate flavor and a stronger peppermint taste.
Blind taste test cookie winner with a 2–1 vote:
ABC Bakers Thin Mints
Lemonades – 75 calories per cookie, 3.5 grams of fat
Strong lemon flavor throughout the cookie with lemon icing on the back.
Lemon-Ups – 70 calories per cookie, 3 grams of fat
More of a shortbread-tasting cookie dipped in lemon icing.
Blind taste-test cookie winner with a 2–1 vote:
Lemonades
Peanut Butter Patties – 65 calories, 3.5 grams of fat
Chocolate tastes like the shell chocolate you put on ice cream and there was a thin layer of peanut butter over the cookie inside.
Tagalongs – 70 calories, 4.5 grams of fat
Smooth and creamy chocolate with a thick layer of peanut butter over the cookie inside.
Blind taste-test cookie winner with a 3–0 vote:
Tagalongs
Caramel DeLites – 65 calories per cookie, 3 grams of fat
Milk chocolate taste with regular coconut flavor and hints of caramel.
Samoas – 70 calories per cookie, 4 grams of fat
More of a toasted coconut flavor with caramel notes. Chocolate tastes richer.
Blind taste-test cookie winner with a 2–1 vote:
Samoas
Peanut Butter Sandwiches – 53 calories per cookie, 2 grams of fat
Strong peanut butter–flavored cookie and rich peanut butter spread inside.
Do-Si-Dos – 53 calories per cookie, 2.33 grams of fat
Cookie has an oatmeal-type flavor with a lighter-tasting peanut butter spread inside.
Blind taste-test cookie winner with a 2–1 vote:
Peanut Butter Sandwiches