Skip To Content
  • Add Yours badge
Updated on Aug 1, 2020. Posted on Jul 5, 2020

What Are Your Most Controversial "One Tree Hill" Opinions?

Brooke and Lucas >> Peyton and Lucas!

If you're like me and love teen dramas, you're probably familiar with the iconic '00s show One Tree Hill.

The WB

It's the story of two estranged half-brothers, Lucas and Nathan, who are forced to get to know each other when they unexpectedly end up on the same basketball team. It's full of love triangles, cheesy lines, and teen angst, and it's glorious.

The WB

So, we want to know: What are your most controversial or unpopular One Tree Hill opinions?

The WB

Maybe you never got all the hype about Haley and Nathan's relationship and thought it was beyond ridiculous that they got married so young. Maybe you even preferred Nathan with Peyton, or would have wanted to see Haley and Lucas together.

Haley and Nathan dance together at their second wedding
The WB

Maybe you actually kind of liked Lucas and Lindsey together and didn't get the hate. Maybe you even thought it was Lucas's best relationship.

Lucas and Lindsey about to get married
The WB

Or maybe you thought Lucas was clearly the superior Scott brother because you preferred Luke's sensitive, introverted nature and his way with words just made you swoon.

The WB

Tell us your most controversial One Tree Hill opinions in the comments! Your response could be featured in a future BuzzFeed Community post.