Skip To Content
    Posted on Jan 3, 2017

    Someone Noticed That "Moana" Basically Has The Same Plot As "The Lord Of The Rings"

    OMG I can't believe how well this lines up. Also, careful, this post has some light spoilers for Moana.

    OK, so, all credit goes to Tumblr user bouncingbumble for this amazing theory. First up, in both Moana and the Lord of the Rings films, there's a small and powerful token that belongs to a powerful being.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    Bouncingbumble told BuzzFeed News they first noticed the similarities between the two films after reading another Tumblr theory about the effect the Heart of Te Fiti had on Grandma Tala.

    "The Heart had basically had the same (just way less sinister) effect on Tala as the Ring had had on Bilbo," they said. " Once that parallel was established, other similarities between the Ring and the Heart, Frodo and Moana, started coming out of the woodwork."

    They added that there was one big difference: the moral alignment of the Heart versus the Ring.

    "The Ring was straight up Evil, no moral gray areas to be found, as was Sauron," They said. "The Heart, though, seems to be integral to Te Fiti’s goodness, who [spoilers] I’d still hesitate to call properly evil even when she’s a justifiably pissed off lava demon."

    The ring is then taken by a flawed hero, who did not truly understand what they were getting in for.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    The hero is defeated and loses the token into the water.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    An eccentric mortal then comes into possession of the item, keeping it for many years.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    They pass it on to a younger relative, before their health immediately starts to deteriorate.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    The young hero is cute, dark-haired, and doe-eyed.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    They wear the token on a necklace.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    And set out to find someone else to take the token.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    But end up having to carry out the quest themselves.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    They are faced with countless obstacles and danger on their journey.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    And make their way to a volcano, where they face their greatest challenge.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    Before finally return the token to its rightful source.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    But wait! There's more! Both feature hometowns that are extremely idyllic and isolated from the rest of the world...

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    Giant birds of prey...

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    Dramatic towers...

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    And boats sailing off into the sunset.

    Disney
    New Line Cinema

    It's 👏 the 👏 same 👏 dang 👏 movie 👏.

    Basically, Moana is The Lord of the Rings but without the evil.

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form