Skip To Content

    Here's 23 Movies That Audiences Loved But Critics Hated, And Vice Versa

    Entertainment is in the eye of the beholder.

    Movie opinions can be...harsh. Critics and audiences alike.

    This leads me to a tale as old as time in Hollywood: Critics and audiences not seeing eye-to-eye in their film reviews.

    A meme about a movie critic and movie fan arguing

    So, I gathered movie scores using Rotten Tomatoes to single out movies that had alarming percentile differences between audience and critics scores:

    *NOTE*: I chose to exclude movies like Star Wars: The Last Jedi, Captain Marvel, Ghostbusters (2016), and others that were subject to "review-bombing" on movie review sites.

    1. Warcraft — 48% difference between critics (28%) and audiences (76%).

    An ogre-looking creature growls

    2. Sausage Party — 32% difference between critics (82%) and audiences (50%).

    Cartoon hotdog looks shocked

    3. But I'm a Cheerleader — 32% difference between critics (42%) and audiences (74%).

    A girl smiles in a pink room

    4. King Kong — 34% difference between critics (84%) and audiences (50%).

    King Kong faces a T-Rex

    5. Antz — 40% difference between critics (92%) and audiences (52%).

    Two ants stuck in gum

    6. The Witch — 31% difference between critics (90%) and audiences (59%).

    A girl in Puritan clothing

    7. Hotel Transylvania — 27% difference between critics (45%) and audiences (72%).

    Dracula in a hotel of monsters

    8. Venom — 50% difference between critics (30%) and audiences (80%).

    Venom sticks his tongue out

    9. Ad Astra — 43% difference between critics (83%) and audiences (40%).

    Brad Pitt in a space suit under red lights

    10. Uncut Gems — 40% difference between critics (92%) and audiences (52%).

    Adam Sandler in "Uncut Gems"

    11. Spy Kids — 47% difference between critics (93%) and audiences (46%).

    two school kids in a beach setting

    12. It Comes at Night — 43% difference between critics (87%) and audiences (44%).

    A man in the candlelight

    13. Harlem Nights — 55% difference between critics (25%) and audiences (80%).

    Eddie Murphy in shock with Della Reese behind him

    14. Grown Ups — 51% difference between critics (11%) and audiences (62%).

    Five friends walk together

    15. Joker — 20% difference between critics (68%) and audiences (88%).

    Joker in an elevator

    16. Transformers — 27% difference between critics (58%) and audiences (85%).

    Optimus Prime ready to fight

    17. Noah — 35% difference between critics (76%) and audiences (41%).

    Russell Crowe as Noah

    18. The Informant! — 35% difference between critics (79%) and audience (44%).

    Matt Damon with a tie, glasses, and mustache

    19. The SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of Water — 27% difference between critics (81%) and audience (54%).

    SpongeBob and friends all buff and out of the water

    20. Playing With Fire — 53% difference between critics (24%) and audience (77%).

    John Cena in a Fire House

    21. Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull — 25% difference between critics (78%) and audience (53%).

    Indiana Jones surrounded by Russians

    22. Drag Me to Hell — 30% difference between critics (92%) and audience (62%).

    Woman stands in a grave while it rains

    23. Twilight — 23% difference between critics (49%) and audience (72%).

    Bella and Edward on a tree

    Can you think of any other movies like these that seemed to split critics and audiences? Comment below!