Pretty Little Liars had a simple-enough premise: In a clique of five girls, one of them disappears. A year later, the four remaining girls start receiving threatening messages about things only their vanished friend would know. But by Season 2, the show had gone completely bonkers, and only got wilder as time went on. Here are 26 moments that prove it:
1. When Hanna got paranoid that Lucas was "A," so she knocked him off a boat and thought she killed him.
2. When Toby let Spencer think he was dead??
3. When they had that Halloween episode where Alison told a fictional story about a girl murdering her twin, and then the twin showed up at Hanna's house the next Halloween.
4. When it turned out Alison was ALIVE after they literally found her body.
5. When a bunch of fake A's just kind of...creepily danced around the Liars in a New York park?
View this video on YouTube
^You really just need to see it to believe it.