1. Matt Damon
2. Kelly Slater
3. Bob Katter
4. Adam Liaw
5. Shane Warne
6. Pinky Beecroft (Machine Gun Fellatio)
7. Bert Newton and Hugh Jackman
8. Guy Pearce
9. David "Kochie" Koch
10. Kasey Chambers
11. Anthony Mundine
12. Ian Kenny (Birds of Tokyo)
13. And finally, Hugh Jackman (again)
Have you met any celebs that were different in person than you imagined? Let us know in the comments!
Some Reddit submissions have been ended for length and/or clarity.