We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
Hey! While we’re doing our best to make sure the products we feature will arrive in time for Christmas, shipping times are tricky and can vary depending on where you live, which product you purchase, and more. Shop early and be sure to double-check the retailers’ websites for shipping information to ensure that your gift will arrive in time for the 25th!
1. A top 100 horror movies scratch off poster they'll probably already be able to scratch a ton off of...but you might be surprised!
Promising review: "I am enjoying this poster so much. I try to keep the next movie a secret until I’m ready to watch it. I’ve seen so many movies I didn’t know about and most of them aren’t half bad! This is a great gift for any horror movie fan." —Carmen Crowell
Get it from Amazon for $29.99.
Shipping info: Will arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
2. A photo pillow custom made with their fave horror meme that you apparently were the 483494745757th person to send to them on IG. As a horror girlie who salivates over 1) Skeet Ulrich in Scream and 2) Flamin' Hot Cheetos, I made this pillow on my own and it's my favorite thing in my apartment.
I indeed found this meme on IG and knew it had to be mine in one physical form or another. So I created a Shutterfly pillow with it! It sits on my couch and often freaks out people I'm video chatting with because it looks like he's always staring at you. It also makes me want some Flamin' Hot Cheetos!
Get it from Shutterfly for $22.99+ (available in various sizes and photo configurations).
Shipping info: Order by Dec. 15 for economy shipping in time for Christmas. Expedited shipping options are also available.
3. A trio of ornaments including Dracula, a werewolf, and Frankenstein just begging for front-and-center positioning on their black Christmas tree.
4. A Jason Voorhees ski mask hat because wearing this will be a much easier expression of Friday the 13th fandom than wearing an actual hockey mask or waiting for a bunch of teenage counselors to come back to Camp Blood.
Promising review: "It is the first glow in the dark item I've bought in a very long time that actually does glow. It's also a nice hat to go with my Freddy Krueger T- shirt." —Sonny G Fausel
Get it from Amazon for $20.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
5. A Freddy Krueger planter in case their neighbors who they wish were just part of a nightmare have a LOT of opinions about their spooky taste or their home doesn't have a yard.
Doolittle Dorks is a US-based shop specializing in pop culture planters.
Promising review: "Absolutely the cutest thing. I purchased Michael Myers for a friend, cause he’s obsessed. Instead of using it as a planter, I closed up the hole on the bottom and having friends who own a candle business, put a candle in there. I would definitely recommend these planters. I actually wanted to keep him for myself, cause he’s so freaking cute." —Candice Tucker
Get it from Doolittle Dorks on Etsy for $25+ (also available with a succulent kit).
Shipping: Costs $9 to ship. Will arrive by Christmas.
6. Some SKIN1004 Zombie Pack Face Masks will make them (briefly) look like their fave kind of horror movie monster while it goes to work tightening pores and minimizing the appearance of wrinkles.
Promising review: "This really works. I am always skeptical of products I buy online because you can't be sure who is posting reviews but I will say that this mask does what it says it will do. I will definitely purchase again." —JEaston
Get a box of eight masks from Amazon for $24.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
7. A Shudder subscription to help satiate their horror hunger — the streaming service has tons of classics, obscure films, and even original shows and movies.
Say it with me: Horror on Netflix sucks! After much hemming and hawing about "Do I need another streaming service?!" I finally got it. Now I'm hooked! I'm a huge horror fan and seek it out year-round. So, TBH, I'm shocked I waited this long! It has lots of exclusive movies (like Color Out of Space with Nic Cage Shudder original ) and TV shows (like Channel Zero, which they've likely heard about), along with stuff you need in your life, such as the 1980 horror classic The Changeling (which is very good) and Henry Portrait of a Serial Killer (truly disturbing, I can't get it out of my head). Anyway, if this at all sounds like it would be appealing to them, you should definitely gift them a subscription!
Sign up for $4.75+/month here.
Psst, if you're a Walking Dead, AMC, Sundance, *or* IFC fan, it's worth signing up for AMC+, which includes access to all of those PLUS Shudder for $6.99+/month.
8. A copy of Dangerous Games to Play in the Dark can bring some creepy fun with games based on urban legends...and eerie illustrations to match.
Get it from Amazon for $11.70 or from Bookshop for $12.09 to support local bookstores.
Shipping info for Amazon: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
Shipping info for Bookshop: Order by Dec. 11.
9. A Michael Myers window decal for the pal who just doesn't watch horror movies. They breathe them too. Their neighbors are gonna LOVE it.
Promising review: "This is so creepy! At the right time of evening, it casts the scariest shadow!! This thing is going to scare everyone away! 😳" —Lola Perez
Get it from Amazon for $7.19.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
10. "Blood bag" drink pouches that'll make the ghostest with the mostest who's always inviting you over to watch horror movies or for spooky shindigs disembody moan with delight. Reviewers say they're super easy to fill!
Promising review: "These added such a cool touch to my Halloween party. Everyone loved using the syringe to get a shot of alcohol and add it to the blood pouch! Easy to use and the stickers made them look super real!" —Marisa
Get a 20-pack from Amazon for $19.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
11. A sign with some Kill, Laugh, Love vibes to give any word signs at Home Goods a run (like, an *actual* run) for their money (or perhaps their life).
Promising review: "Got this for my son for his birthday. We love horror movies and this was so perfect! 🥰😂" —LisaD.
Get it from Amazon for $9.69.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
12. A Nightmare Before Christmas cookbook in case this is definitely the least gory of their faves but they never miss a chance to go to Disney Parks to see Jack Skellington's seasonal takeover of The Haunted Mansion...and they seemingly have every other piece of Nightmare merch ever.
Get it from Amazon for $19.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
13. An ~spooky~ garlic chopper inspired by Dracula because they never do a Bram Stoker's Dracula rewatch without eating some cheesy garlic bread. This'll help them skip to the good part.
You can also use it to chop nuts, fruits, and veggies!
Promising review: "I purchased this as a gift for my friend who is a fantastic cook — she uses fresh ingredients almost exclusively — but pressing fresh garlic is a task usually delegated. No longer — Gracula is there for her. She uses him nearly every time she needs garlic (which is basically daily) and months later still makes a point of saying how much she enjoys the gift. I'm pretty sure she likes it better than other gifts I've gotten her which were more expensive/thought out, and I'm fairly certain it's what took me from 'good friend' to 'best friend,' but it be that way sometimes. Anyway, definitely recommended for people who cook with garlic and have a sense of humor." —L
Get it from Amazon for $22.95.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
14. A Pearl T-shirt because baby, they're gonna be a star. No matter what.
Little Donna's is a New York-based small biz specializing in retro-inspired clothing, accessories, and more.
Get it from Little Donna's on Etsy for $25.05+ (available in sizes XS–3XL).
Shipping info: Costs $4.35 to ship and will arrive in time for Christmas.
15. Plus an axe pizza cutter to keep the theme going for any "good for her" pizza and movie nights.
Promising review: "Gave as a gift. They got a good chuckle out of it..." —Kathleen W.
Get it from Amazon for $6.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
16. The Final Girl Support Group for the pal who more or less only reads horror but you haven't seen them post this on their IG stories or Goodreads. They'll have a blast because yes it's an excellent book (I loved it!) but also because they'll get a thrill out of matching each "Final Girl" with each horror movie franchise.
And! A TV show adaptation has been announced for this. So they can get ahead of the game and read this before it comes out. I read this awhile back right after it came out (I've read *all* of Grady Hendrix's books and he's one of my favorite authors) and got through it so quickly that I was a bit sad when I finished it. A few other Hendrix's books that are highly giftable are The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires and Horrorstor.
Get it from Amazon for $12.18 or Bookshop for $15.81 to support local bookstores.
Shipping info for Amazon: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
Shipping info for Bookshop: Order by Dec. 11.
17. A spooky wax melt warmer if you don't dabble in the macabre and know they always have a candle lit or some kind of warm fragrance any time you go to their place.
Promising review: "This is awesome for Halloween! Or if you just love skulls. Has a beautiful eerie glow when turned on with wax!" —Laurel Darhali
Get it from Amazon for $26.99 (available in six more styles).
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
18. Or a spine candle in case regular ole tapers won't suffice for their creepy abode and you don't want to dig too much to find out specifics about their horror faves — less they sniff out that you're their Secret Santa. (Dang true-crime podcasts and their excellent sleuthing!)
Promising review: "Super cool!! The candle makes me feel like being in the classroom of Professor Lupin learning how to cast a Patronus! Very cute decor!!" —Yvette
Get it from Amazon for $19.99 (also available in white).
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
19. And because we're going with a bit of a theme here, a skeleton-in-a-cauldron candle who just looks *so* relaxed. After all, nothing calms your recipient like sitting down with a big bowl of popcorn to watch an obscure '80s slasher.
Promising review: "This candle is AHHHMAZING!! One of the best Halloween decor purchases I have ever made. I love how it looks like he’s taking a bath! It is the perfect combination of spooky, cute and relaxing. I think I’ll display this candle year round." —Michael Burnham
Get it from Amazon for $29.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
20. A Chucky Chia Pet that'll be their new friend 'til the end because every time they ask you if you've actually watched the new Chucky TV show as you've suggested (it's great, btw), you say "not yet" and therefore drop down a notch in the friend rankings.
Promising review: "The two-sided Chucky is great! Easy to apply the Chia seeds all around. I would suggest following the directions for a successful growth if not familiar with Chia Pets." —Trish
Get it from Amazon for $22.73.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
21. A lagoon monster print (that I own and love!) in case they're as into glam as they are into monsters. We exist!
I also have this print! This LA-based company was founded by Mexican-born artist, Ilse Valfré. You'll love each item more than the last. I've also bought a shirt and phone cases that are more or less compliment bait.
Get it from Valfre for $48.
Shipping info: Allow up to 5 days for this item to ship.
22. A Ouija Board welcome mat as a lil' preview for what folks can expect when they stroll in for movie night.
Promising review: "This mat was perfect this Halloween, it adds the perfect amount of subtle eeriness and it held up really well under our covered doorway. I'm sure this will last for at least another three years. The ink is clear and the words are legible (which was a concern I had prior to it arriving). But, despite the inexpensive price tag, it's actually a well-made mat that's true to the provided picture." —Morgan Benedict
Get it from Amazon for $24.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
23. A Lost Boys enamel pin they can sport to their next hangout with new pals.
I've bought enamel pins from this store before and they've been top-notch! And feel free to tell the recipient all about this biz because it's catered to horror enthusiasts and has some deep cuts.
Jad is Rad is a Las Vegas-based small biz that specializes in funny, spooky fashion and accessories for horror fans.
Get it from Etsy for $7 or Jad is Rad for $10.
Shipping info for Etsy: Costs $3.99 to ship. Will arrive in time for Christmas.
Shipping info for Jad is Rad: Can take up to 14 days for processing.
24. An Evil Dead / Scooby-Doo mashup art print of Thelma reading the Necromicon because maybe she was in a weird mood? (Zoinks!!) I'd like to think this is happening in a scary cabin villa on Spooky Island.
Scream Prints is a Lansing, Michigan-based small biz featuring tons of amazing horror mashup prints and other art!
Promising review: "This Scooby Doo/Evil Dead crossover print is the sickest shit I've ever seen. The entire concept of horror crossovers is so cool, but this one is VERY me. The print itself came perfectly packaged in a poster tube, looks and feels high quality. It was also priced so cheap, I spent less than $12 on this. I feel like you could've charged me $112 and I would've been like, Yes reasonable, you deserve it." —Samantha Bell
Get it from Scream Prints on Etsy for $10.50.
Shipping info: Ships for free and will arrive before Christmas.
25. Or an Army of Dark Chocolate coffee for anyone who considers a stroooong cup of dark coffee their Boomstick. Can you even call them a loved one if they haven't sat you down and made you watch Army of Darkness?
Promising review: “Just get it. You will love it. Chocolate coffee, need i say more!!" —Amanda Y
Get it from Bones Coffee for $15.99 (available in ground or whole bean).
Basically every coffee from this brand has a horror tie-in, so if coffee and horror are their thing but they'd prefer something else then check out the other flavors.
Shipping info: Beans are roasted daily so orders take about a week to fulfill. Shipping can take up to 7 days but expedited options are available.
26. Plus a coffee mug with something sinister lurking beneath the surface they'll have to face once they get through their first cup of the day.
Promising review: "My favorite mug now. Very sturdy and super cool.I drank coffee, tea, juice, and even wine in it, and it never got stained. Now I want the other designs as well. Highly recommended." —Christiane
Get it from Amazon for $13.99.
And check out more "creature" cups your gift recipient might like here.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
27. A Hereditary treehouse gingerbread house kit — complete with worshippers inside — to help start a new family tradition.
Get it from A24 for $62.
Shipping info: U.S. orders $75+ ship for free. Orders under $75 cost $5 to ship. Place your order by Dec. 12 for guaranteed delivery by Christmas.
28. A superbly cozy movie-watching blanket that'll seriously come in handy because she *is* just a girl who loves horror movies.
Promising review: "My wife loves this blanket! It describes her perfectly as she loves her horror movies! It is extremely soft and lightweight. Perfect for the warmer months. The quality is really nice and it looks just like the photos." —Brian "SpookYouLaterz" Lubecki
Get it from Amazon for $29.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
29. A lovey-dovey pair of salt and pepper shakers with chemistry that's clearly electrifying. It'll make 'em say "aww" every time their meal needs a little more seasoning.
Promising review: "Got them as a gift for a Halloween-loving friend. They are just adorable." —Gomez
Get them from Amazon for $15.95.
Also check out a magnetic vampire pair.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
30. A trio of Scrub Daddy ghouls for the clean freak who loves to put on their fave slasher while they REALLY scrub every square inch of the house. Um, talk about practical!
Promising review: "I feel like it’s pretty self-explanatory that these sponges work amazing and don’t scratch anything. When I saw the Halloween designs I had to have them and I was not disappointed. They hold up well just like any other scrub daddy. The color doesn’t fade or bleed into hot water and there’s no smell to the sponges. This is the best Scrub Daddy design. The bottom of the ghost and the top of the Frankenstein get right down into all the good spots on my cups. Plus they’re adorable." —MamaBear276
Get three packs of three sponges each from Amazon for $22.49.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
31. An Overlook hotel poster because it's been on their bucket list ever since they saw that great travel doc about it, The Shining.
Promising review: "Love that this is a sly aside to The Shining. Those that know the movie/book will get it and those that don’t know the movie/book will be blissfully unaware that you love a good scare. The vintage travel advertisement style is well crafted and well executed. I’d love to see more titles in this series (Rose Red Mansion; Rabbit in Red Lounge; Gatlin, Nebraska; Cornwall Coombe, Hårga)." —SLY
Get it from Amazon for $5.50+ (available in six sizes and five formats).
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
32. An A24 coffee table book of The Witch with the screenplay in a gorgeous presentation they'll wanna show off to anyone who enters their lair.
33. A pastel goth shower curtain sure to bring some cheer(?!) to their bathroom.
Tbh, I've had this bookmarked because I've been mulling it over for my own bathroom.
Promising review: "Love this shower curtain!!! Perfect for spooky season. I’ve gotten so many compliments on it. It’s decently thick, great quality, and the color is exactly as pictured! Buy it." —Chyna
Get it from Amazon for $21.99.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
34. A ticket stub collecting notebook if they hold onto every single movie ticket stub and haven't quite figured out what to do with them yet.
Promising review: "This ticket album was just what I needed for all of my concert tickets and memorabilia. There was plenty of room for multiple ticket stubs/guitar picks/other memorabilia in each slot on the page. The ticket album arrived quickly and in good condition. I am very pleased with my purchase and would definitely recommend." —Amanda
Get it from Amazon for $15.99.
Shipping: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
35. A Krampus Christmas ornament complete with a basket full of naughty kids. Who needs Elf of the Shelf when you can hang this at eye level on the tree? Gotta love an excuse to watch the holiday film by the same name.
Promising review: "When I realized that my kids were getting a little too entitled when it came to gift expectations, I knew some old school motivation would help. Adding Krampus to our tree decorations serves as a constant, watchful reminder that the holidays are not a 'win-win' for kids — there's an expectation and requirement to be humble and kind in exchange for the rewards they expect...and violent, rage-filled punishment in a copper pot or burlap sack if they don't meet those requirements.
Sounds like a healthy addition to any child's formative years to me, and I'm happy with my purchase!" —Bradums
Get it from Amazon for $14.95. Also check out the matching tree topper.
Shipping info: Available on Amazon Prime with 2-day shipping, non-Prime shipping options will still arrive by Christmas (see Amazon's full shipping information here).
36. And speaking of Elf on a Shelf, if they'd want a less creepy version of it (YEAH, I said it!), a Lily "haunted" doll can help serve the same purpose.
37. Or! A special unsettling toy to add to their spooky-but-not-explicitly-Halloween collection of decor.
Unsettling Toys started in Portland, Oregon in 2019 by partners Sara Derrickson Brian Jillsonas with the idea of a matchmaking agency for unwanted toys. At the very least I urge you to follow the biz on Instagram. The account is great!
This is Bella, one of many toys that the folks at Unsettling Toys are trying to rehome. The linked page shows the dolls available for "adoption" right now and you can even look at a gallery of "adopted" toys for some inspo on which one will be right for your home. The owners also looooove receiving unsettling toys once you email them with a bit of a backstory. The dolls are sometimes haunted, but of course there's no guarantee.
Get it from Unsettling Toys for $50.
Shipping info: Ships for free. Contact the shop owners for more details.
Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.