Promising Review: "In the picture, I'm wearing CoverGirl's LashBlast Fusion in Blackest Black on the left, and Physicians Formula Organic Wear in Ultra Black on the right. PROS: Easy to apply, non-clumping, good color, good volume, good length, my lashes don't feel as damaged as they do with other mascaras. In fact, it seems to provide moisture to them. CONS: Not at ALL waterproof. Overall, it is a good mascara, I just wish they had a waterproof version of it. I think I will keep using it, as it is the best and most affordable cruelty-free mascara I've found so far. I just use it for a light, everyday look. Seriously though, don't cry when wearing this unless you want to look like the Winter Soldier." —Amelia
Get it on Amazon for $11.09 (cruelty-free and PETA-certified).