1. Coffee and coffee syrup from Dave's Coffee, RI
3. Cream sodas and seltzers from Boylan, NY
4. Kringles and other Danish pastries from O&H Danish Bakery, WI
5. Pickles and pickled veggies from Rick's Picks, NY
7. Tamales and salsas from Texas Tamale Company, TX
9. Spicy mustard from Philippe the Original, CA
10. Cincinnati chili (not your regular kind of chili) from Cincinnati, OH
11. BBQ sauce and ribs from Meat Mitch, KS
13. Touvelle, cheddars, and blue cheeses from Rogue Creamery, OR
14. Beef jerky from Brooklyn Biltong, NY
16. Pastrami, knishes, and reuben from Katz's Delicatessen, NY
18. Biscuits and pimiento cheese from Callie's Hot Little Biscuit, SC
19. Lox, other smoked fish, pickled goods, and more from Barney Greengrass, NY
22. Coffee and tea from Philz Coffee, CA
23. Crazy caramel brownie creations from Killer Brownie, OH.
24. Hot and spicy cheese bread from Stella's Bakery, WI
25. Fresh juices and seasonal fruit from Red Jacket Orchards, NY
26. Chicago-style deep dish pizza from Gino's East, IL
27. Nutella chocolate babka, croissants, and other baked goods from Breads Bakery, NY
28. Apple pies baked in a bag and other goods from The Elegant Farmer, WI
29. Salami and sausage from Olympia Provisions, OR
31. Alfajores and other dulce de leche treats from Limanjar Dulcería, NY
34. Cookie dough pints from Cookie Do, NY
35. Kouign-amans from Les Madeleines, UT
36. Cheesecakes and pies (including the mile high apple pie) from Blue Owl Bakery, MO
37. Boozy ice cream from Tipsy Scoop, NY
If you want to check out other local eateries that ship nationwide, check out Goldbely!
Want even more great product suggestions? Sign up for BuzzFeed’s Gift Guide Newsletter!
If you can't see the signup box above, just go here to sign up!