What she's up to now: After Casey's Laguna Beach days ended, she studied pre-law and psychology at Pepperdine University. In 2009, Casey opened Casey's Cupcakes, a cupcakery in Riverside, Calif. In 2011, Casey's love for cupcakes landed her on TLC's Cupcake Wars, and she won the show's "Walk of Fame" episode. As of 2014, there are now five Casey's Cupakes in Southern California.