They say that Day-Lewis' motivations are unclear, that his acting is gimmicky, and that his histrionics take the viewer out of the action. In other words, they think he's a ham. Of course, hamming it up has always been a pretty good way to win yourself a gold statue.
Editorial note: Whoa! You've found a super-old post here on BuzzFeed, from an earlier era of the site. It doesn't really represent where we are anymore, and may in fact be totally broken, but we're leaving it up as a part of our early history.